Give me your pound for pound top 5

You do realise that P4P means: If every fighter in the world weighed exactly the same weight and fought each other TODAY who would win...

Anyone with BHop in their top5 is ****ing deluded.

 

Agreed.

 

1) Joe Calzaghe
2) Mikkel Kessler
3) Jeff Lacy
4) Robin Reid
5) Peter Manfredo

 

omg, did Kessler's corner even have a cutman during that fight?

Calzaghe vs Pac as #2 is an interesting Dilemma. pfp matchup would be one helluva fight.

 

Accomplishments do not count??

 

Not at all. If a guy has a lot of victories over very good people recently, it makes it a bit easier to justify your choice, but thats absolutely not what Pound for Pound means

 

Mayweather
Hopkins
Pacquiao
Calzaghe
Cotto

 

well if its a paded record then you have a case, but if it included beating great fighter then it should count, because how else are you going to analyze a fighter without including his victories over other great fighters?:huh

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr
Joe Calzaghe
Juan Diaz
Manny Pacquiao/Juan Manuel Marquez
Wladimir Klitschko

 

Floyd

JMM

Calzaghe

B-hop/Cotto

Iron boy

 

With all respect, but:

 

1 PBF

2 Super Joe

3 Pac Man

4 Cotto

5 B-hop

I'm expecting to see B-hop drop in everyones rankings as soon as his fight against JC is announced. When JC beats him he'll be ''42 and shot''.

 

PBF
Pac
Joe
BHop
JMM

 

Mayweather
Calzaghe
Hopkins
Miguel Cotto
Manny Pacquiao

 

1) Mayweather
2) PacMan
3) Calzaghe
4) tie Rafael/Izzy
5) Hatton

You have no idea how much it hurts to have two Brits in the top 5!:desk :cus