Give me your top 10 P4P

Wow I'm the only one with Ruslan...

 

You have him over Garcia who beat Matthysse and Khan?

You have him over Martinez?


Who did he beat to legitimize that? Enlighten us please.

I am sick and tired of P4P ratings, they're a waste of time imo.
Ruslan Provodnikov is a top 140lbs'er, thats all that really matters.

 

1. JMM

2. Canelo

3. JCC jr

4. Jhonny Gonzalez

5. Estrada

6. Andy Ruiz

7. Abner Mares

8. Herrera

9. Floyd

10. Ward

 

Some people thought Murray beat Martinez.
Overwhelming majority thought Herrera beat Garcia.

Lot of people thought Ruslan beat Bradley, who is ring magazines number 3.
Ruslan just knocked out Alvarado.

My list is based on these criteria:


my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins - very strong emphasis on this category
2) stature in own Division. Extra points for being top fighters of competitive divisions
3)career accomplishments
4) least important is excitement

 

1.Ward
2.Wlad
3.Void
4.Bradley
5.Rigo
6.Froch
7.Pac
8.Stevenson
9.Lara
10.Garcia

 

All Ruslan has done is nearly beat Bradley and beat Alvarado. Golovkin has no good wins lol, its a bad list your basing it too much on excitement

 

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Guillermo Rigondeaux
3. Timothy Bradley
4. Andre Ward
5. Sergio Martinez
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7. Manny Pacquiao
8. Wladimir Klitschko
9. Danny Garcia
10. Gennady Golovkin

 

Bradley way too high, how can he be ahead of Ward when Ward has never lost?

 

Well Bradley has also never lost (officially), he has fought and beat better opposition imo and has proven himself in more than one weight division. If Ward beats the likes of Kovalev and Stevenson at 175 I would put him higher, possibly #1 depending on how impressive he looks and what my current top 3 do.

 

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Andre Ward
3. Timothy Bradley
4. Wladimir Klitschko
5. Guillermo Rigondeaux
6. Sergio Martinez
7. Danny Garcia (Looked bad in his last fight but he still undefeated with big names on his record)
8. JMM
9. Manny Pacquiao
10. Adonis Stevenson

 

Lol 'officially' so you scored it for Bradley too?

 

Pacquiao vs Bradley? I've never actually sat down and scored it. Looked like Pacquiao won at the time but that wouldn't change my rankings anyway.

 

Ward is yet to face an elite fighter, Bradleys resume shits all over Wards

Should Kell Brook be above Bradley cos hes never lost?

 

your list is not that bad jas, at least you don't have martinez on like all the other nostalgics around here.
but you should really look more into the lower weight divisions.

 

Brook is barely top 100

They both have good wins, difference is Ward's fights have never been close Bradley hasnt looked as unbeatable has Ward has

If people are saying Bradley officially won then why is anyone bringing up Martinez vs Murray, Martine got a UD officially