Go back, Jack, view it again...we're scoring, Round By Round...

Dude, I barely have time these days to watch these three minute videos, let alone a 40 minute long fight!!

But, as I recall, I had the first one close for Shumenov. The second fight I never saw.

 

actually youre scoring is pretty objective and i enjoy your rbr threads as most if all if not all the riff-raff here dont participate.

 

I like this idea.....can we place VCASH and then re-score the fight:nut

:smoke

 

The guys who talk the loudest are always missing on Fight Night for scoring.:good

:smoke

 

can you do pascal-hopkins 1?

 

I've read.the thread IB, so im not just tryin to **** you off...

But iirc I couldn't find Kessler vs Froch (2, I think) in your archive and always wanted to see how you'd have called that one.

:guitar

 

Just wanted to say BRAVO on the thread title. I didn't even get the reference when I read it this morning lol!

 

IB,

Might it be a good idea to sticky this thread?

 

I agree , great thread IB.

I might add, I know the point of your thread , but I really dont get the time these days to watch many fights and actually read your RBR's after the fight.

I would appreciate your analysis on Mayweather vs Hatton if you get the chance.

peace.

 

My scorecard for Shumenov vs. Campillo I.

Fight watched start to finish, no replaying any sections, with short notes taken in the minute between rounds.

Round 1, 10-9 Shumenov
Very clear. Pushed him around. As usual Shumenov spent a lot of energy but Campillo clearly feeling it out, throwing only a handful of punches.

Round 2, 10-9 Shumenov, 20-18 Shumenov
Campillo shows a pulse and lands educated shots, but ultimately too few. Shumenov wins with his crude aggression. Shumenov's movement backwards is yet to be a negative in "ring generalship."

Round 3, 10-9 Shumenov, 30-27 Shumenov
Campillo's ineffective pressure in a round Shumenov made a lot of mistakes in let him down. Shumenov took momentum back with the mid round flurry and held off Campillo from anything beyond 1-2's.

Round 4, 10-9 Campillo, 39-37 Shumenov
First round Campillo is active enough to overcome early point deficit Shumenov establishes out of the gate. Campillo lands good punches including a showcase beaut uppercut toward the end. Blocks Shumenov greatly over the last two minutes.

Round 5, 10-9 Shumenov, 49-46 Shumenov
Pretty close. Frustrating for Campillo as it was much like the 3rd round. Campillo actually missing shots and looking poor with his placement for first time all fight.

Round 6, 10-9 Campillo, 58-56 Shumenov
A stalking Campillo begins to walk Beibut down and land shots at will, despite Shumenov's usual pattern of big early flurry and occassional hard shot through the guard or sweeping to the body. Campillo looks comfortable for the first time in the fight.

Round 7, 10-9 Campillo, 67-66 Shumenov
More or less, probably less on both fighters' accounts, of Round 6.

Round 8, 10-9 Shumenov, 77-75 Shumenov
Both have successes and failures with what they've been trying to do all fight. Slightest edge to Shumenov in this seemingly toss-up-ish round, largely on activity. Too much activity.

Round 9, 10-8 Shumenov, 87-83 Shumenov
Campillo appears to be taking advantage of a tired Shumenov, clearly winning the round, until getting clipped and going down. Maybe 25% slip. 100% legit, though. Shumenov contempt with the +2 advantage gained in the round and moves until the bell.

Round 10, 10-9 Campillo, 96-93 Shumenov
With exaggerated bending of the waist and foot movement, Shumenov avoids action all round in a clear effort to survive. Very close to a 10-8 round.

Round 11, 10-9 Campillo, 105-103 Shumenov
Not as dominant as the last round, but these Campillo rounds are clearer than the earlier and middle rounds. Campillo now besting every single exchange and landing with good accuracy. His finding of his range is impressive and unstoppable by a gassed Shumenov.

Round 12, 10-8 Campillo
Shumenov starts by having his best round in several. He looks to be impressively mustering will and courage in fighting back until getting dropped by a straight to the body. Then, he musters will and courage for another reason. He makes it to the final bell with a few more exaggerated waist bends and head tilting.

Final score: 113-113 Draw

IB, we have the same score but VERY different means of getting there... Interesting and fun stuff! A pleasant fight to watch indeed.

 

how about pacquaio-mayweather.........oh wait..........never mind.

 

I started watching & scoring it on saturday, but my GF had another ideas about what I should do with my free time... like cleaning my home :|

I'm afraid I've not idea about scoring, but I saw the first five rounds and... Shumenov starts the rounds agressively, throwing those wide combinations for the first 30 or 45 seconds, and then backpedals for two minutes without landing nothing. Campillo blocks most of his loaded punches and them walks him down for two minutes and scores IMO the cleaner shots (Campillo's pillowfist trademark :deal).

I'll try to find a moment tomorrow to finish the work and upload my scoring.

Pwill-Martinez I next week? :happy