Gotta be honest, most aficionados had Castillo & Maidana beating TBE. Discuss please.

Castillo has a good argument to win and Maidana at best a draw as he clearly won 4 or 5 of the first 5

However most aficionados thought he beat Maidana, don't try and rewrite the truth

 

I believe both Castillo & Maidana beat Mayweather. Plus Mayweather should have been DQ'd against both Ortiz, for his cowardly ambush of a totally defenceless opponent & for Roger jumping in ring & attacking Judah. Uncle Joe Cortez REALLY proved his blatant bias in both cases

 

Have a vote on here & I'd bet the majority pick Maidana as the winner Mayweather BARELY scraped by a one armed sabotaged Pacquaio too

 

Why is it you Mayweather maniacs accuse everyone who posts the TRUTH about that worthless POS gets accused of hating him ??? He CHEATED !!!!!!!!!!!!! I HAVENT SEEN A SINGLE ONE OF HIS WORSHIPPERS OFFER UP A LEGITIMATE EXCUSE FOR HIM.

 

Vote on here yea right. So all the alts can come out and play

Did any reputable writers or pundits have Floyd lose

 

Yes several did actually Most of the others know Floyd COULDNT LOSE or be allowed to lose in Vegas
The 118-110 cards were made out before theyd even climbed in ring

 

Castillo won the first fight 7-5.

Maidana also won the first fight 7-5. After the first 6 rounds, one can argue that Maidana was up 5-1, and some people reasonably did.

 

How can someone be TBE (that means "the best ever", right?) if they got beat by Castillo and Maidana?

 

Void had close fights with Maidana, Cotto, Dela Hoya and Castillo. But got bailed out by the judges as usual.

 

Boxing is corrupt. Castillo overwhelmingly decisioned an injured Mayweather. But since boxing is corrupt, marketability matters more than integrity, and pieces of offal like Jerry Roth judged with their wallet, thereby making me pay extra for another fight I wanted to see, Cotto-Mayweather, because his record was 'untarnished.' It's a scam. The Thai judge should never be allowed to score a fight again.

 

• Al Bernstein, Showtime: Mayweather 115-114
• Jake Donovan, *******.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Steve Farhood: Mayweather 115-113
• Doug Fischer, Editor RingTV.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Lyle Fitzimmons, *******.com: Mayweather 116-112
• Norm Frauenheim, The Ring Magazine, www.15rounds.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Jeffrey Freeman, www.KODigest.TV: Mayweather 116-113
• Tom Gray, RingTV.com: Mayweather 115-113
• David Greisman, *******.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Keith Idec, The Record/*******.com: Mayweather 116-112
• Matt Hamilton, ESNewsReporting.com: Mayweather 116-112
• Kevin Iole, Yahoo Sports: Mayweather 115-113
• Marc Livitz, SecondsOut.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Paulie Malignaggi, Showtime: Mayweather 115-114
• Ryan Maquinana, CSN Bay Area/*******.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Rich Marotta, KFI Radio, Los Angeles: Mayweather 115-11
• Diego Morilla, XN Sports: Mayweather 116-112
• Jack Obermayer, Fight Fax Inc.: Mayweather 115-113
• John J. Raspanti, Doghouseboxing.com/KO Monthly Magazine/examiner.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Matt Richardson, Fightnews.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Chris Robinson, Hustleboss.com/*******.com: Mayweather 116-112
• Cliff Rold, *******.com: Draw, 114-114
• Michael Rosenthal, The Ring Magazine: Mayweather 115-113
• Abel Sanchez, trainer of WBA middleweight titleholder Gennady Golovkin: Mayweather 116-112
• Lem Satterfield, RingTV.com: Mayweather 118-110
• Tamas Sasvari, Monokli.com: Mayweather 115-113
• Dominic Verdin, RingTV.com: Mayweather 116-11
• Anson Wainwright, RingTV.com: Mayweather 116-112

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php?title=Fight:1869533

 

You sound like you got a personal issue with the man. That's your business cause you are entitled to believe whatever you want to, However the fact is that the man is 49/0 whenever you get through running your trap. As for excuses, I don't make excuses for grown men, the facts speaks for themselves and the fact is that the man is undefeated.

 

So you've posted those that said Mayweather, although there were others who said draw and Maidana victory (they were in the minority but still enough numbers to make it intriguing).

The problem with what you posted is that any two people who gave it to Mayweather by even 1 round definitely disagree on what rounds they awarded Maidana..that makes a case for a Maidana victory.
One phenomena people are guilty of when scoring fights is that they will give a round to a certain fighter because of what they did in one round, relative to another, without taking into full consideration the success the opponent was having. This makes it very easy in this situation to give Mayweather a round or two because he's not a high energy, high output fighter anyway so it's easy to compare to other rounds.

 

I thought Maidana had a case for 1-5 and 12 but 2 was close and 12 was a stretch

I posted those scores to refute the original post declaring most observers had Floyd lose to Maidana which is a dishonest work of fiction

I myself in other threads said the 114-114 score was fair and the 117-111 score was way off base