Greatest legacy Calzaghe,Mosley,Trinidad,De La Hoya,Wright

In terms of a two weight champ with a 10 year title reign and never losing, people could vote for him......

I wouldnt but thats certainly a decent legacy, just nowhere near Oscars

1.Oscar
2.Joe
3.Tito
4.Shane
5.Winky

 

:happy I've been making the same point from the first moment I arrived here.

It's the Fanboy Playground. It is utterly ridiculous and totally unjustifiable to say Calzaghe has a greater legacy than De La Hoya, but the biased fanboys will vote for their hero in every poll irrespective of the poll subject. Pathetic.

 

LMFAO, and you give DLH CREDIT for fighting a "smurf."

 

1. Oscar
2. Trinidad
3. Joe
4. Mosely
5. Winky

I Voted for Trinidad because he beat a lot of the fighters Oscar gets credit for first.

 

well he is the p4p best with wicked power.......normally he's not a smurf....but he's essentially gonna be compared to DLH

 

1. Oscar
2. Trinidad
3. Mosley
4. Calzaghe
5. Wright

 

Im one of Calzaghes biggest fans as you know pacfan, but he doesnt get close to topping this list

you must admit he leaves a very decent legacy overall though??

 

That would be my list based on their resumes

As a 'legacy' Calzaghe is up at 2 or 3

 

He does, And I hate the guy.

 

you don't even know him . what do you mean you hate him ?

 

Wicked power at 126-130, fought an AVERAGE belt holder at 135, and now he's going to fight a guy who has fought the following guys with MUCH MORE poweratsch

BHOP, Mayorga, Tito, Mosley, Mayweather, Quartey, Vargas,

 

im making the point that he's still fighting the guys considered the best and never compared pacquiao to the pther guys on his record dude

 

I would be tempted to leave Calzaghe at 4 on legacy - Mosley was a three weight champ (and completely bypassed 140) and though I am not really a big Trinidad fan his accomplishments are considerable.

Beating a shot Jones does nothing for Joe - in fact his resume would have been better had he quit after Hopkins, to be honest. Because he didn't stop Jones, I feel he needs to carry on.

 

jones was just for a name and for cash lets be honest......

where would mayweather fit though if we added him??

 

Dude i never meet Cotto neither and i used to hate him aswell, I guess im the only boxing fan who hates a fighter.

Just mention mayweather and you will discover a million more like me lol. (I dont hate floyd by the way, his the best)