Greatest legacy Calzaghe,Mosley,Trinidad,De La Hoya,Wright

Oscar.

 

Oscar
Tito
Joe C.
Winky
Shane

 

no offence to the makers of this poll but how the **** does winky wright get put up for consideration above bernard hopkins?

 

He managed a draw with ATG Jermaine Taylor....

 

I voted DLH but have no problem with anyone thinking that someone with 10years as a champion, 2 wieght champ and retiring undfeated also deserves equal credit. Each to there own

 

I don't think he was put up ahead of Hopkins, just instead of him. The guy is asking a question thats all, I don't see the implication that the thread-starter is saying these five are better than any guys who aren't included in this specific thread.

 

Well done !




You get the prize for the first correct answer.



(Keep in mind, all five, with the possible exception of Tito, are still creating their lagacy).

 

Right now Joe has a greater legacy than Tito??

Number of world titles won: Tito wins
Number of weight divisions titles won in: Tito wins
Resume: Tito wins

Prize taken back and given to me.

 

Ssm

 

A boxer's legacy is subjective.

It depends on how you weight the different attributes.

mrplow ranked them in the order I would have, therefore, I awarded him the prize.

(For whatever it's worth !)

 

De La Hoya, this isnt close.

 

dude dont say it like that, be nice because Calzaghe fans will soon start making all kinds of stupid polls if you insult him like that.

 

If Tito has these three things in his favour:

Number of world titles won: Tito wins
Number of weight divisions titles won in: Tito wins
Resume: Tito wins

Then how does Calzaghe have a greater legacy?

A 9-year WBO title reign encompassing fights against some of the very worst people to ever challenge for a major world title?

 

holy **** i agree with you. im off to shoot myself:rofl