Greatest legacy Calzaghe,Mosley,Trinidad,De La Hoya,Wright

I voted for Mosely,

 

Trinidad or De La Hoya

 

I understand everyone voting for Oscar, but to me "resume" and "legacy" are two entirely different things. Some of you must rate Zab Judah pretty high too since he lost to a bunch of champs. Resume should help enhance your legacy IF you actually win some of the big fights which Oscar seldom seemed to do. He lost to Hopkins, Mosely x2, Trinidad, tiny PacMan, PBF, and a faded Whitaker made him look like a ****** flailing around trying to catch a fish with his hands.

I'm not disputing the man's resume, but his results were lackluster at best.

 

Winky beat Mosley but when Mosley was over his good weight and a little older. He beat Tito when Tito was older. I just do not think Winky should be number one or even 2.

 

no i wouldn't simply because winky made his mark clearly once shane gave him a foot in the door, but there's more depth to what mosley achieved.

even after winky beat shane twice and tito he faded back into relative obscurity again because he priced himself out of fights.

for a guy trying to cut it as a promoter also i would have thought he had more reason than most to make fights happen.

 

De La Hoya clear winner....
Tito second!
Mosley third!
Calzaghe
Wright

 

At his prime he ruled......

 

i think you nailed it perfectly.