Greatest Of All Time

Terrible list. Very inconsistent, here's mine.

HW: Muhammad Ali
CW: Evander Holyfield
LHW: Ezzard Charles
SMW: Roy Jones Jr./Joe Calzaghe
MW: Harry Greb
JMW: Mike McCallum
WW: Ray Robinson
JWW: Aaron Pryor
LW: Benny Leonard
SFW: Floyd Mayweather Jr./Alexis Arguello
FW: Willie Pep
SBW: Wilfredo Gomez
BW: Eder Jofre
JBW: Jiro Watanabe
FlyW: Pascual Perez/Jimmy Wilde
JFlyW: Jung Koo Chang/Michael Carbajal
SW: Ricardo Lopez

 

If you were going to put Hearns in, switch him up at JMW, no way he belongs at #1 at WW.

 

Forgot about Watanabe. That's a good pick.

 

I liked the pick of Roman as well, I'm simply getting out of the habit of putting Galaxy in there, never felt he deserved it, and I've been getting big into the lower weight classes recently. Watanabe is definitely one I'd choose to outbox Galaxy handily.

 

Heavy Ali
Cruiser Holyfield
Light-Heavy Michael Spinks
Super-Middle Joe Calzaghe
Middle Monzon
Light-Middle Hearns
Welter Robinson, Leonard
Light Welter Pryor
Lightweight Duran
Super Feather Arguello
Feather Salvador Sanchez
Super Bantam Joan Guzman
Bantam Eder Jofre
Super-Fly Cristian Mijares
Fly Pascaul Perez
Light-Fly Carbajal
Minimum Ricardo Lopez

 

Is this an ATG/H2H mix list?

 

Surely must be H2H if he has Joan Guzman as the best super-bantamweight of all-time. Some people might also say Spinks is a joke on his list, but not half as bad as Guzman.

Not sure why Guzman would be on the list H2H either.

 

That makes two of us. I know Amsterdam loves him, though I've never gotten it really. Good fighter, very talented, but certainly not better than the likes of Gomez or Morales.

 

Heavy - Muhammad Ali
Cruiser - Evander Holyfield
Light heavy - Ezzard Charles
Super middle - Joe Calzaghe
Middle - Harry Greb
Light middle - Mike McCallum
Welter - Sugar Ray Robinson
Light welter - Aaron Pryor
Lightweight - Roberto Duran
Super feather - Alexis Argüello (I almost put Acelino Freitas)
Feather - Willie Pep
Super bantam - Wilfredo Gómez
Bantam - Eder Jofre

 

Heavy = Ali
Cruiser = Holyfield
Light Heavy = RJJ
Super Middle = Calzaghe
Middleweight = Hagler
Light Middle = Sugar Ray Leonard
Welterweight = Sugar Ray Robinson
Light Welter = J.C. Chavez
Lightweight = Pernell Whitaker
Super Feather = Floyd Mayweather

I stop it here....

 

How do you think a match between Morales and Gomez would go?

 

i know.That is the 1 division were there is NO argument.I mean that literally.

 

Heavyweight: Muhammad Ali

Cruiserweight: Evander Holyfield

Light-Heavyweight: Archie Moore

Super-Middleweight: Joe Calzaghe

Middleweight: Carlos Monzon

Light-Middleweight: Terry Norris

Welterweight: Ray Robinson

Light Welterweight: Julio Cesar Chavez

Lightweight: Roberto Duran

Super Featherweight: Floyd Mayweather

Featherweight: Willie Pep

Super Bantamweight: Wilfredo Gomez

Bantamweight: Eder Jofre

Super-Flyweight: Khaosai Galaxy

Flyweight: Jimmy Wilde

Minimumweight: Ricardo Lopez

 

At best, he could be the #4 heavyweight of all time...if he dominates 4 or 5 more years and beats 5 more contenders, cleaning his division.

 

I think I'm one of few who looks at it from a stylistic standpoint. Most would assume, given how outstanding and flawless Gomez seemed at the weight, that he beats everyone who ever fought there. Looking at it from my standpoint, he got beat by a naturally bigger man in Sanchez at 126, one who could take a punch, counter-punch, dish back in combination, and hurt you. Morales was much the same way. However, Gomez was better at 122 than 126, and Morales would not have the size advantage to that degree at this weight.

Gomez was perhaps an even harder hitter and better finisher than Morales at 122, a more fluid fighter, more technically sound, but Morales has the height and reach edge, along with the ability to take some of Gomez's best punches and dish em back. If the fight got down to a brawl, I'd take Gomez to land the cleaner shots, but I also think Morales could hurt him. I think Gomez was a better pure boxer, but Morales's edges in length could give Gomez trouble in that regard as well.

As far as how I think the matchup goes, I'd take Gomez to outland Morales, but Gomez to be on the canvas at some point during the fight. I think with fighters of this nature, a brawl would undoubtedly come about, and Gomez(much like Barrera) would land the better shots, especially inside. I'd take Gomez in a close decision, though he may hit the canvas at some point. Would be a barn-burner for sure.