Greatest P4P boxer of all time?

Frankly, what annoys me a bit here is (in general): Somebody creates something that takes maybe a little bit of effort and contributes something to the forum's activity (e.g., a top list of fighters). Afterwards come the cherry-picking critics and know-it-alls (How could you rate fighter x on No. 50 etc...)

Then you have to justify...

I explained before why I included Mayweather who was still 6times The Ring P4P fighter of the year and somebody already voted for him here (but nobody for Joe Louis).

I am not a fan of him either and I am not a Mayweather expert. I know he tells a lot of stuff (but it's pretty uninteresting to me) and is disputed which is also a reason why I have him in this poll (not my personal rating!).

Anyway, there are 9 other choices and you can write your own favorites in this thread.

 

Well, there are many great old boxers like: Joe Gans, Archie Moore, Benny Leonard, Mickey Walker, Tony Canzoneri, Barney Ross, Willie Pep, Sandy Saddler, Jack Britton, Jimmy McLarnin, Jimmy Wilde etc….
You can mention them.
As I wrote earlier, there are only 10 choices.
Also, I didn't want to take only old fighters (more of a mix). If someone is interested in a comparison or poll between older fighters or boxers at a certain period of time, just open a new thread.

 

No worry, buddy, it's already forgotten.
I mean a respectful disagree, objective criticism with good arguments is always appropriate.

I just mean, in general, stuff like: you're full of ****, you know nothing, liar, you are delusional etc... which I read sometimes here (rather in older threads) doesn't belong to that. Maybe some of that stuff is just fun or slang and I don't get it because I am not a native speaker. Well, but the internet today (you know what I mean) it's not the everyday language.

Your post, on the other hand, is harmless (just Mickey Mouse )

Whatever. I can understand the criticism of Mayweather. I could also choose Manny Pacquiao, that I personally prefer, as a boxer from today. But I thought Mayweather could be more interesting in a poll because he has more haters but maybe also more hardcore fans (but I am not sure about).