In this scenario, Greb beats (and that is not a variable) Jake LaMotta Randolph Turpin Bob Olson Rocky Graziano Gene Fulmer Carmen Basilio Paul Pender Joey Giardello Sugar Ray Robinson Where do these wins rank out all of his existing collection? I'd say that Robinson ranks as number 1, it at least 2. I'd put LaMotta above guys like Tiger Flowers and on par with Norfolk and Bartfield Turpin, Olson, Pender and Graziano wouldn't make the top 10, for me anyway. Basilio and Fulmer would be good wins, and if they cracked the top 10 they'd be like 9/10, so not near the top really. I'd say Giardello is worthy of being higher than them. Maybe 7/8 My top 10 (based of my pfp top 50) 1. Sugar Ray Robinson 2. Tommy Loughran 3. Mickey Walker 4. Maxie Rosenbloom 5. Gene Tunney 6. Kid Norfolk 7. Joey Giardello 8. Jake LaMotta 9. Soldier Bartfield 10. Tommy Gibbons
Welcome back! I'd rank the Robinson win right under the Tunney win as Greb's second best win. It'd go something like 1. Tunney 2. Robinson 3. Walker 4. Loughran 5. LaMotta 6. Tommy Gibbons 7. Rosenbloom 8. Fullmer 9. Mike Gibbons 10. Jack Dillon Flowers just barely didn't make the list
The difference for me was that Tunney was a light heavyweight and Robinson was a welterweight, but Robinson def >>> p4p