let's not get carried away with P4P ratings. kats was a good performance (not great) and I follow all aussie boxers in decent fights (incl cumdine). but quite simply there is no way you can put kats ahead of green in p4p. 90% of you gave green no chance yet a ko'd a future hall of famer coming off what people saw as a masterful performance of the old days (against lacy). kevin mitchell- what has he done? with all due respect, nothing! katsidis is the best name on his record by far. as such, no one that is impartial and uses some logic, which is ny on impossible for some of you, can argue with P4P being; 1. Vic 2. Green 3. Kats It also has nothing to do with where they fight! If kats had the support don't you think he would fight here? that aint greens (or cumdines) problem! he should go get a big sponsor to back him in! if someone in a reasonable way show me where this logic is wrong I will gladly reconsider??
Fair argument Shiner. Was rapped at the time for Green with his performance against RJJ. But Roy's performance against Hopkins provided further indication of where his career is at - ie shot to bits and should be retired.
and some of you guys think 20a87 is a lovestruck troll.RJJ has been shot to **** for 5 years.the 100 plus people who voted for him on that poll were yanks.Lacy has been ****ed since Calzaghe and Tsypko where hefought with a torn rotator cuff.Katsidis lost to Casamayor and Diaz.Green lost to the most pissweak SMW champion going in Marcus Beyer and was schooled hopelessly by Mundine having no future he moved to LHW where his best win was Stipe Drews.and now instead of taking on the young guns at CW hes chasing MW Mundine. aussie P4P TOP 5 1.Vic Darchynian 2.Michael Katsidis 3.Anthony Mundine 4.Danny Green 5.Daniel Geale
Good solid argument SM - but you're giving the lovesick Troll way too much credit. 90% of what he writes is just lovesick Mundine b/s mate.
I'll pu my hand straight up and say I picked Jones to win, as did the majority, and as did the betting agencies. Most were deceived by the Lacy win - including me. Hindsight is indeed a wonderful thing.
Tell us again about how Green won against Roy with a 'barely legal punch' Lefty, and how it was stopped prematurely, oh, and don't leave out handwraps!
...and he's bagged him unmercilously since! Whinged for weeks about Green's 'illegal blow' that he later modified to the 'barely legal blow' etc, etc. ...hates Green with a very rare passion!
I don't hate anyone my friend. I just think that Green is a fake and a phony who lacks character. Yeah and I think that fight was a complete sham, dirty punch and then over without seeing anything from either fighter. I see that Green adopted 'the chopping punch to the back of the head' for the Siaca fight aswell.
thats right he did didnt he.but i went to community and dug up MSTR's old thread and lefty voted Green.he just doesnt like him.