GSP v SAKURABA....... Who Wins ?

Discussion in 'MMA Forum' started by Bill Butcher, Feb 19, 2009.


  1. Bill Butcher

    Bill Butcher Erik`El Terrible`Morales Full Member

    28,518
    82
    Sep 3, 2007
    Sakuraba is a far superior wrestler than either Penn or Serra, they couldnt stop the takedown nor score any takedowns to put GSP in a bad position (on bottom or made to work from his guard)
    Sak is also bigger than those 2 guys, he punches & kicks harder & as far as applying submissions in MMA fights I rate him higher than Penn & Serra.
    (Straight grappling might be different, especially vs Penn but in MMA, Sak was a 10/10 submission specialist.)

    If Sak doesnt submit or KO GSP, it could be a close one due to GSPs high workrate but I still think Sak would have scored enough dominant positions & strikes to take it on points.

    A more difficult to call fight would be Sak v Andy Silva, GSP wouldnt beat Sakuraba IMO, Id probably back Sak v Silva never mind GSP.
     
  2. sugarngold

    sugarngold RIDDUM Full Member

    18,550
    5
    Jun 10, 2007
  3. québecwarrior

    québecwarrior Georges 'Rush' St-Pierre Full Member

    6,938
    0
    Jun 5, 2007
    That DONT matter how good Sakuraba is good in wrestling, because he ISNT on GSP'S level, Sak wouldnt score one dominant position. If Kos cannot take GSP's down with one leg, Sakuraba wont. And common, I do agree that sakuraba would have a chance to submit him, but KO GSP? Since when GSP take blow to the head minus Serra 1? GSP is seriously hard to hit clean. Fitch did connect 2 right hands and Penn in the first fight landed a fair amount of blow, but nothing who troubled GSP, and Sakuraba don't have that accuracy to trouble GSP whos more slick and better footwork.

    GSP by being the more evolved fighter over a guy who was a beast back then but didnt have all the training, nutrition that a guy like GSP have.
    GSP TKO in the second round, after giving Sakubara trouble with his GnP in the 1st round.
     
  4. Utter1

    Utter1 Active Member Full Member

    978
    0
    Mar 5, 2006
    Why does Rashad Evands get such a bad rap?
     
  5. OuterDrake

    OuterDrake Guest

    Lets see,he beats the old ufc generation(primarily 1d fighters)


    Sakuraba should have walked through Cro Cop and Manhoef with his ground game.But his stand up is not in par to even stall the fight for a perfect takedown.

    Thus being 1D fighter(borderline)
     
  6. Koa

    Koa Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,380
    3
    Sep 24, 2004
    The guy tries. He just has nothing special other than wrestling, which is used more to nullify. There is nothing dynamic, or electric, or exciting about him. Strikes are powerful, but quite sloppy.

    Compare this guy to Rampage.. I mean what the ****? What is it that Rampage has that Evans doesn't as far as pedigree, and opportunity? Back when Rampage had almost no standup training, he was a better striker than Rashad. Rampage's wrestling ability is superb, he has what would be considered very good experience, but not a pedigree like Rashad.

    I guess I'm just upset that Rampage had the championship taken from him in the first place. He didn't lose that fight with Forrest, and no way in hell do I believe Forrest BEAT Rampage, so I have a feeling, more that Rashad is an illegitimate champ in the first place. I think THIS is why I don't like him. Watching him, just feels like watching a scrub.. Its like watching a scrub, who beat a scrub who was given a gift I guess.

    As much as I think Diego Sanchez is a tool, I still recognize he is a dynamic fighter, and I recognize Kos as a dynamic fighter as well. If either of them Got a belt, I wouldn't be so upset. They somehow seem to be more refined/ clean.

    Its like the game has gone from looking for victory via counter, or dynamic refined skill, to winning a fight via low risk, low reward exchanges due to the ability to nullify entire skill sets.
     
  7. Bill Butcher

    Bill Butcher Erik`El Terrible`Morales Full Member

    28,518
    82
    Sep 3, 2007
    Cro-cop was a full HWT & in those yrs was beating Josh Barnett 3 times & giving prime Nog & Fedor all they could handle + Sakuraba was giving a fantastic acount of himself before the doctor/referee stopped the fight because his eye socket was smashed to pieces & Sak still wanted to fight on.
    Can you imagine GSP vs Cro-cop ?
    1 kick & :dead for George, lets get real here.

    To mention Manhoef`s name in order to discredit Sakuraba is like mentioning Berbick`s name to discredit Ali, the man is a complete shell of himself & should have retired many yrs ago, Im talking primes here, Sak would break GSPs arm in 2-3 rds.
     
  8. Bill Butcher

    Bill Butcher Erik`El Terrible`Morales Full Member

    28,518
    82
    Sep 3, 2007
    It DOES matter that Sakuraba is a great wrestler & he IS on George`s level.
    He had trouble taking Penn down when he was fresh in the 1st rd, Penn is MUCH smaller & NOWHERE NEAR as good a wrestler as Saku, once GSP keeps trying to get Sak down & cant, then tries to outstrike him & gets his thighs smashed up you will see him make basic mistakes of which Sak will take full advantage of, eventually Sak will get him to the ground & his black belt level BJJ skills will not be enough to stop Sak applying a submission after a few mongolian chops & solid punches.

    Also... I wish people would STFU about the sport having evolved so much with training & nutrients, what a crock of ****, seriously, its not as if Saku fought in the ****in 50s, his prime was from about 98-01/02.
    Thats like saying a prime Roy Jones couldnt compete now.

    Sakuraba ALWAYS trained extremely hard in his prime... the man went an hour & a half with Royce Gracie then later that SAME NIGHT came out & had an even fight with HEAVYWEIGHT Igor Vovchanchan.

    GSP has A LOT to do before he can be compared to Sakuraba IMO.
     
  9. québecwarrior

    québecwarrior Georges 'Rush' St-Pierre Full Member

    6,938
    0
    Jun 5, 2007
    Penn stopped the takedown from the CLINCH in the first round. Its not GSP's bread and butter who are takedown from distance where he shoot. Sakuraba never fought an athlete AND hardworker like GSP, never. You really believe GSP will not be able to take down Sakuraba:lol::lol::lol:What make you think so? Name me a better wrestler that Sakuraba fought than GSP and who wasnt able to take him down? The only place Sakuraba have a chance to submit GSP is from his back. GSP will outwrestle, outhustle, outpower him EVEN if he is the smaller man. Watch GSP-Serra 1 if you want to believe yourself about that.
    GSP is faster, stronger, better footwork, better stamina, better standing, better GnP, better coaching.


    GSP TKO 2
     
  10. Bill Butcher

    Bill Butcher Erik`El Terrible`Morales Full Member

    28,518
    82
    Sep 3, 2007
    Obviously you havent seen a prime Sakuraba fight to utter such crazy statements.
    I dont why you mention the 1st Serra fight, that only hurts your arguement, I probably wouldnt have brought that up as I feel Serra got plain lucky & the much better overall fighter lost that night.
    GSP out-wrestles WELTERWEIGHTS because he is always the much stronger man, Sakuraba would play with GSP, prevent the takedowns & destroy GSPs thighs with kicks, GSP would get the better of the punching IMO but would take a fair few himself & harder ones at that.

    How do you know GSP has better stamina than Sakuraba, the guy fought for 90mins then came out & fought another 15mins vs someone that much bigger & stronger that it would never be allowed in UFC even in a one-off fight never mind a tourney.

    When GSP comes up against an opponent that can take him a solid 5 rd fight, then we can talk stamina, until then you cant compare stamina with a fighter of Saku`s stamina, he was always tip top shape in his prime.

    You do know that Sakuraba used to beat BIG Lt-HWTs right ? as pride never had a Lt-HWT division.
    GSP hasnt even proved he can hang with MWTs yet never mind Lt-HWTs.

    Sakuraba`s wrestling pedigree is of an extremely high level, no way GSP manhandles him the way he did Penn, Serra, Toscheck & co.

    Go watch Sakuraba vs......
    Silvera, White, Newton, Goes, Belfort, Fontes Braga, the Gracies (Royce, Royler, Renzo, Ryan), Vovchanchan, Rampage, Wanderlei II, Randlemann, Nogueira, Cro-cop......
    then we can try work out a plan for GSP to beat that version, I dont like our chances but we`ll give it a shot.

    Maybe the nutrients & `modern` training will help :rofl
     
  11. québecwarrior

    québecwarrior Georges 'Rush' St-Pierre Full Member

    6,938
    0
    Jun 5, 2007
    Anyway you must think that a prime Ken Shamrock beat a prime Lyoto Machida right?or Bruce Lee would beat BJ Penn ?
    any i've made my points, I did watch Sakuraba vs the gracies, all his fight with Wandy, the fight with Randleman, his fight vs Rampage ect ect, and I did see ****in Carlos Newton takin him down and takin his back.
    je taime
    :thumbsup:thumbsup
     
  12. Bill Butcher

    Bill Butcher Erik`El Terrible`Morales Full Member

    28,518
    82
    Sep 3, 2007
    Quebec.....

    1. If you had watched Saku in his prime vs those guys then I believe your opinion of him would be higher.

    2. If you have seen those fights I mentioned, watch them again, you missed something.

    3. When GSP starts taking Evans down in real fights, then we can talk.

    4. Toscheck being a great college wrestler has got nothing to do with anything, I never said GSPs wrestling was bad, I said Sakuraba`s is better than you give him credit for.

    5. That version of Machida was nothing to the more complete & just plain better version we see today, Machida would absolutely **** both BJ & GSP if they fought today.

    6. Im not saying GSP have bad stamina, Im saying Sakuraba proved his stamina more than GSP has til this point, lets see GSP in a real tough distance fight & get confirmation of what you (& I for that matter) believe, that GSP has great stamina.

    7. Sakuraba by armbar rd 3 over GSP, this wouldnt even be Sakuraba`s toughest win.


    Ps. The sport has went thru some evolutions but I dont see that it has improved THAT MUCH that a well rounded, well conditioned guy like Sakuraba wouldnt be able to be just as strong a force now as he was then, no way, not enough yrs have passed to make such a claim & Ive been watching MMA for about 10 yrs + seen about 95% of the fights that happened before I started following it.

    :good
     
  13. québecwarrior

    québecwarrior Georges 'Rush' St-Pierre Full Member

    6,938
    0
    Jun 5, 2007
    as I edited
    any i've made my points, I did watch Sakuraba vs the gracies, all his fight with Wandy, the fight with Randleman, his fight vs Rampage ect ect, and I did see ****in Carlos Newton takin him down and takin his back.
     
  14. québecwarrior

    québecwarrior Georges 'Rush' St-Pierre Full Member

    6,938
    0
    Jun 5, 2007
    oh and it may seem that i'm agressive over this subject, but i'm not, its only that my english make it sound like this:good
     
  15. Bill Butcher

    Bill Butcher Erik`El Terrible`Morales Full Member

    28,518
    82
    Sep 3, 2007
    I seen Carlos Newton take Dan Henderson down aswell but he didnt keep him there just like he didnt keep Sakuraba there & 1 takedown doesnt make you a better wrestler, its a fight, stuff happens.
    Sak likes to give his back, he loves the high level BJJ guys trying to sub him from that position then he goes for his own sub`s.
    I do BJJ & usually when even a purple belt has your back its game over, Sak used to give the ****in GRACIES his back & never came close to being submitted.
    Renzo Gracie gave GSP his black belt, Sak nearly halved Renzo`s arm in 2 via kimura.

    Saku`s submissions were a work of art, I think he takes GSPs arm back home to Japan as a souvenier personally but I know Im not gonna change your mind, I can tell by your name & avater. :D

    :thumbsup