HW: A mashup of Lewis, Ali, Holmes and Holyfield for me. CW: Tie between Holyfield & Usyk. LHW: Tie between Ezzard Charles & Bob Foster. MW: Tie between Hagler and Hearns. WW: Thomas Hearns & SRR I can't think of the H2H GOATs of the lower weight divisions after welterweight. What's your H2H GOAT list of these 5 weight classes ?
All I know is that I want to watch a round robin of those HW on your list. I also hope we are getting pre-exile Ali, because otherwise, my money is on Lewis for their H2H. His combo of height, reach, and boxing skills, combined with his power, might be too much. And I also want to see TH vs SRR at WW. I know, I'm going all off topic, but so what.
Mm Ali could beat the most but he could lose. Cruiser? Evander probably. Ezzard Charles or Archie Moore (Easy pick) At 160lbs Let’s say Monzon? Tiger or Hagler is also fine. Not too keen on Tiger… 147lbs is just Sugar Ray Robinson, Hearns isn’t close to Ray at all pretty much no welters are.
Heavyweight: Muhammad Ali Cruiserweight: Oleksandr Usyk Light-Heavyweight: Ezzard Charles / Roy Jones Middleweight: Marvin Hagler Welterweight: Sugar Ray Robinson Lightweight: Roberto Duran / Pernell Whitaker
Hearns beat Shuler,Dewitt and Roldan at 160lbs,he doesn't belong anywhere near a top10 at middle imo.
Heavyweight: Muhammad Ali or Joe Louis Cruiserweight: Oleksandr Usyk Light-Heavyweight: Ezzard Charles Middleweight: Harry Greb Welterweight: Sugar Ray Robinson
Heavyweight: Mike Tyson, Muhammad Ali, Joe Louis Cruiserweight: Evander Holyfield, Oleksandr Usyk, Light Heavyweight: Roy Jones Jr, Micheal Spinks, Ezzard Charles Middleweight: Marvin Hagler, Carlos Monzon, Bernard Hopkins Welterweight: Sugar Ray Robinson, Sugar Ray Leonard, Floyd Mayweather Jr. Lightweight: Roberto Duran, Joe Gans, Pernell Whitaker
Hearns ahead of Leonard at welterweight? Who does Tommy beat that Leonard can’t? It’s often very hard because styles make fights but Ali, Holyfield, Charles, Robinson, Robinson would be my picks.
Heavyweight: Ali Light Heavyweight: Charles Middleweight: Monzon Welterweight: Robinson Lightweight: Duran Featherweight: Saddler Bantamweight: Olivares Flyweight: Wilde
