Had Oscar won the fights he lost, would he be considered top 10 all time great?

Yes. ****, he may be the greatest of all time with that record and resume.

 

If Reggie Strickland had also won all of the fights that HE lost he would be the #1 ATG even ahead of DLH.
http://www.boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_id=4741&cat=boxer

 

Even with an undefeated record R S's resume would not compare to DLH's.................................................Oh you were jokingatsch

 

I would say yes. His resume is stacked with alot of HOF and ATGs. He may not have won them all but based on his resume i consider him to be higher ATG than Mayweather. Of course Mayweather could surpass him if he cleans up WW.

 

Is this thread serious?

If I had been born in England and was the ******* child of Prince Phillip from a liason with Marylin Monroe and he and Queen Elizabeth had no other children and the queen forgave him and agreed to adopt me then I could be the King of England? OMG!!

 

I personally don't like Oscar but he was great for boxing in his prime, great action style he put on great fights and he took on all challenges which is something that I hope stays in this sport we love so much. I think the same can be said about Trinidad Mosley and De la hoya, All 3 of these guys resumes are absolutely stacked if they would have won all their fights, they would have been top 10.