has mayweather surpassed whitaker?

mayweather is a head of sweat pea

 

Beat an all time great

 

They are close, but I think Mayweather is a bit better.

 

floyd best oscar

oscar beat sweet pea

i think there resumes are compareable

ill take floyd to UD pernrell prime for prime.,

 

God no!!

Watch Whitaker vs Nelson. Then bow your head in contrition.

 

Yes

 

We're all reconsidering Floyd's status in the ATG category because he knocked out an over-rated, over-eager, junior welterweight?

Floyd still needs to beat a great prime fighter. Hatton is a good fighter that wasn't fighting at his natural weight. You don't become better than the likes of Pernell Whitaker on tonights performance.

 

Whitaker was robbed when he fought Oscar. He knocked him down, made him miss all night long, and outlanded him.

 

ur kiddin right? Look I find Floyd more explosive. but he needs to face and beat someone as great as him in their prime or close to it like a Cotto. Sweet Pea beat JCC, Nelson in their primes and defensively, Pea was better, he goes thru rounds without getting hit

 

Pea was close to being shot when he fought Oscar. Im being decent to not bring it up

 

Mayweather punches a bit harder. But for sheer skillful all round boxing, Whitaker. Especially defense, and variety of defensive moves.

 

floyd is greater than sweet pea I would post the numbers but the haters wouldn't care:deal

 

This is a great question. I have to think about this. PBF has done great things, but Whitaker was amazing, even though I didn't like how he fought.

 

Yes! He was already coked up and he still made Oscar look foolish.