Has Mayweather surpassed Whitaker?

Ripcity, you give Mayweather the head to head edge over Pea? Did I get that right? How?

Pea has the key advantages in this fight, and matches Mayweather in his strengths.

 

He was talking about Mayweather against other great 130 lbers. Although H2H, Floyd beats Pernell like a pinata.

 

Really?

 

Damnit. Ok, you got me. I like Whitaker H2H. I was trying to make you come at me with an anger filled response.

 

Like a pinata?! hahaha

 

Resume? I don't know, maybe...I don't really care. That's not part of my judging criteria, and I don't keep current p4p or ATG lists based on accomplishment.

As far as demonstrable talent? I don't know...he's shown glimpses of the total package SPW was at his best...but hasn't mirrored it. Yet. Who knows what the future holds?

 

The Shadow knows!

 

You're thinking of the evil that lurks in the hearts of men. :roll:

 

Right-o! I guess nobody knows then.

 

Least of all Alec Baldwin. F him in the A.

 

yes...equal skills but Floyd is just a more dynamic fighter

 

Alec Baldwin, leader of F.A.G

 

Floyd is passing his prime, he will show no improvements. In fact, as he has moved up he has only become less and less impressive.

 

Alec Baldwin is awesome and hilarious, ever seen Along Came Polly? But the Shadow was a low point.