Hatton or Calzaghe?

Discussion in 'British Boxing Forum' started by The Exile, Jun 21, 2007.

  1. The Exile

    The Exile FUBAR Full Member

    818
    1
    Aug 17, 2004
    Both great fighters!

    Both No1 in there divisions!

    Both have have many fans and detractors for different reasons!

    Who is best pound for pound?
     
  2. China_hand_Joe

    China_hand_Joe Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,217
    11
    Sep 21, 2006
    Hatton seems very human.
     
  3. jc

    jc Boxing Junkie Full Member

    13,972
    13
    Sep 9, 2004
    Talent and Longjevity is the reason I say Calzaghe is better. Though Joe has yet to beat that pound for pounder i still think he pips hatton to the post.
     
  4. The Exile

    The Exile FUBAR Full Member

    818
    1
    Aug 17, 2004


    Didnt realise Cazaghe was a cyborg :D
     
  5. mike464

    mike464 Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,846
    0
    Sep 10, 2005
    this is how I see it: They both defended micky mouse belts many times before stepping up (Hatton against Zoo, Calzaghe against Lacy). I rate Zoo as P4P better than Lacy, so Hatton has the edge there but still a great win for Joe. After their big wins, Hatton unified and won a title at 147 while Calzaghe beat Bika and Manfredo (a fight that should never have happened). Again, Hatton has a small edge. However, if Calzaghe can beat Kessler I'd give it to him, even if Hatton beats Castillo.
     
  6. victorhugo4222

    victorhugo4222 Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,509
    0
    May 29, 2007
    I think you have to say Hatton just for the fact he had the balls to leave Warren and stop being a ''protected fighter'' and go try fight the best in the US. I wouldnt say Callazo or urango are the best fighters out there but Hatton seems to be moving in the right direction with fighting castillo. Hopefully joe will to by fighting kessler and then maybe mundine but until then i have to say hatton.
     
  7. Strike

    Strike Boxing Addict banned

    3,983
    0
    Sep 14, 2004
    I am a Hatton fan and I don't really like Calzaghe. But Calzaghe is the more talented boxer and even though he was in the comfort zone for far too long he has fought better opp than Hatton and would beat the best in his division and the divison above, the same cannot be said for Hatton.
     
  8. LeedsLad

    LeedsLad Active Member Full Member

    1,132
    0
    Apr 11, 2007
    Calzaghe on boxing ability. I respect Hatton for going across the pond and trying to make a real name for himself worldwide, but Calzaghe has been the top dog in SMW for 10 years and is a super talented fighter. If he was American he would easily be recognised as top 5 P4P worldwide.
     
  9. PrideOfWales

    PrideOfWales Winston Zedmore Full Member

    11,685
    1
    Apr 20, 2006
    I'd agree with the comments above.
     
  10. The Exile

    The Exile FUBAR Full Member

    818
    1
    Aug 17, 2004
    I'd pick Calzaghe personally but think Hatton has achieved more.

    I just wish we could have seen Joe in bigger fights, hopefully the next year will give him the big one's (said that for years now).
     
  11. stake501

    stake501 Active Member Full Member

    1,238
    1
    Apr 7, 2007
    hatton for balls

    Calzaghe fior talent
     
  12. PrideOfWales

    PrideOfWales Winston Zedmore Full Member

    11,685
    1
    Apr 20, 2006
    Unfortunately, if I'm honest, I'm sure everyone will think back in 5 years time and theoretically ask each other "Could Joe Calzaghe have beaten.... Benn, Eubank (prime), Collins, Watson, RJJ, Ottke, Kessler, Hopkins, Taylor, Winky, Froch & Tarver". We could all speculate but will have no hard answers.

    Oh and if you're Australian reading this.. two points: No, Mundine shouldn't be there and **** off back to your own board.
     
  13. Farmboxer

    Farmboxer Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    86,109
    4,076
    Jul 19, 2004
  14. deram

    deram Active Member Full Member

    528
    0
    Nov 14, 2004
    I think Hatton is no. 1 in his division (in the sense that I think he is the best). I don't think Calzaghe is necessarily no. 1 nor the best in his division. Two guys are clearly ahead of the rest there.

    However, p4p Calzaghe is at another level to Hatton imo.
     
  15. morsey

    morsey Member Full Member

    155
    0
    Mar 24, 2006
    This just about sums it up. Calzaghe all the talent in the world, just not in the fights to display it