Hatton had a good Chin in his prime so I'd go with him because a solid Chin in addition to a stout heart beats supreme physicality melded with a Glass Heart, Glass Jaw, and Glass Body. I imagine Hatton would get raked going to the inside early on but Judah would slow down due to his abysmal gas tank and the early body work and then it would be a foregone conclusion. The glass shatters soon after.
Really dissapointed this never happened. I think a prime Hatton walks him down and makes Judah quit around about the 10th round.
50/50 fight. Judah definitely has the power to hurt and KO Hatton, who was pretty poor defensively and doesn't have the length or speed of Khan to fight him like he did. But Hatton's ugly, mauling style could also take Judah out of his comfort zone for a late stoppage too.
Hatton. He may have not had as much talent as Zab, but he had a world class mentality. Zab would fold from the pressure and find a way to lose.
The more I think about it I see Zab gettin himself dqd. Both dirty fighters, but Zabs an emotional dirty fighter so he would blatantly retaliate and probably complain to the ref all night till he had enough
