Hatton Vs Judah, who's legacy is greater?

Hatton KO 1.

 

Hatton ruled the LW division for years.

Hatton and Hatton.

 

with out proving himself to be the best lww in britain:huh
this is where the debate all falls apart

 

your gonna say junior witter aren't you? atsch

 

let's see....one guy is done and has been put to sleep twice....the other guy is still fighting and has won titles in two divisions. hmmmm.

 

Oh god, not this again. atsch

Some people will never be happy unless a boxer defeats every other fighter in the world at his weight.

Hatton faced (and beat) much better than Witter.

 

hatton needed help from the ref and hometown crowd. his best win was against a guy who had a year layoff due to injury.

 

hatton won titles in 2divisions. .

it's close. .. but id say hatton. . but if judah puts together some decent title defenses over the next 2-3 years and doesnt quit again, the him. .

talent/potential, it's judah.

 

atsch

 

hatton would walk through him and punch holes in zabs body!

 

I think it is very close.. Judah may even have an edge.. But legacy is useually how we remember them (imo)..

Hatton will always be remembered as the tough guys who did everything he could but fell short against the very best.. Judah will be remembered as the guy who had all the talent in the world, but crumbled and quit when things got tough..

 

and prime for prime, id take hatton.

 

Judah lost to every top level fighter he faced.

And even lost to journeyman.

Hatton's two losses were against the best two fighters of his generation.

Resume wise i give the edge to Hatton with wins over KT,Collazo,Malignagi,Urango etc but its close.

My answer is Hatton.

But they are two of the most overrated fighters in the last 15 years.

 

Judah easily.

Wrestling a shot to **** Zoo then getting embarassingly KTFO twice doesn't make you great.