Hatton's improvement and Graham/Mayweather Sr

Discussion in 'British Boxing Forum' started by TFFP, Apr 28, 2009.


  1. TFFP

    TFFP The Eskimo

    45,002
    3
    Nov 28, 2007
    I was thinking about Billy Graham in bed last night. There was a thread on him, I think that is the reason, or I hope so. It got me thinking, one burning question.

    Did Graham improve Hatton from the period of Vilches, Stewart and Oliveira (The late WBU days) up until Paulie Malignaggi? That is a period of 4 years, 2004-2008. He undoubtedly did well to take him from a kid into world class, but did he have a ceiling as a trainer at this point?

    Are there any particular areas of his game you look at and can recognise a significant difference?

    Evidence for the jury to consider at intermittent periods:

    12/11/2004
    [YT]cdaLrZd4xWE[/YT]

    06/04/2005
    [YT]ay0FhU-0DlA[/YT]

    23/06/2007
    [YT]6UeYWanxhfs[/YT]

    24/05/2008
    [YT]cjQoOtmQ3zQ[/YT]

    My personal opinion is NO. Hatton did not improve during this period. My reasons for this are that when I consider Hatton's performances, it is no surprise to see his best performances are when he is highly motivated, as against p4p fighters Tszyu and Castillo. When he had less fire in him, he put up more lacklustre performances, such as Urango and Lazcano. It seems to be purely down to Hatton's own intensity as to whether he performs to his maximum. That infers he is trading on his own mentality, he's not really gradually improving fight on fight or thinking about what he did in the gym. I think if there was a graph of Hatton's performances levels they would be scattergun, whereas Pacquiao's would be a gradual upward curve. That is when this dawned on me.

    Also, how do you explain how his best performance is in one particular fight against Tszyu, and from there on he never quite reached the same level? He can hardly of peaked after one fight.

    I don't notice anything inparticular that stands out as being improved from the earlier days after watching the video.

    I also hear that Mayweather Sr has supposedly improved Hatton in the Malignaggi fight. This is what people are saying. That being the case, how did Mayweather Sr do in a few weeks what Graham could not do over years? Is this not a damning indictment on Graham that Hatton could improve over such a short space of time? That suggests he had some potential in him to improve on his boxing ability that was never far underneath the surface yet Graham never unlocked it.

    Thoughts.
     
  2. Beeston Brawler

    Beeston Brawler Comical Ali-egedly Full Member

    46,399
    15
    Jan 9, 2008
    Good post.

    I feel that they got complacent...... having scaled the mountain (so to speak) in defeating Tszyu, and having come up with an excellent, albeit reckless gameplan in order to do so, they simply decided that it would work against anybody.

    Instead of actually sticking to those tactics, they went one step further, trying to KO each opponent in the first round. See Maussa and Collazo for this especially (Urango being the exception) - after decking Collazo in the 1st ten seconds he punched himself out pretty much by the end of the 2nd round..... rather than coming up with a gameplan to attempt to take away certain elements from their opponent.

    In the Collazo fight he was being hit with the sneaky left all night, it was only the KD and the 11th round, together with the sporadic use of his straight right that got him over the line.

    I also felt they underestimated Mayweather's ability to FIGHT. Everybody knew that he was a great boxer, but they didn't study enough tapes of Mayweather to realise this. They simply watched the 1st Castillo fight and the DLH one, and decided that pressure was the way to go. Obviously, trying to box Mayweather would have failed, but after the first three rounds all we saw was him lunging forward in straight lines and being picked off, before being manhandled and outfought later on.

    In the later Graham years, we saw Hatton become one-handed.

    For me, Floyd sr didn't make that much of an improvement. All he did was get him back to the style he used against Phillips and Tackie - always aggressive, but thinking.... using feignts, drawing the lead, countering with rights rather than lunging lefts....

    This camp might have improved him further.... all will be revealed I guess :good
     
  3. TFFP

    TFFP The Eskimo

    45,002
    3
    Nov 28, 2007
    In a way that is what I'm getting at. They did what they did against Tszyu, which is fine, but Graham didn't realise that blueprint is not the right blueprint against every single fighter out there. Tszyu is a guy you don't give a minutes peace, that is well known. That does not work for everybody, and that is a tactical failing of Graham aside from not improving him. You can't expect a guy to fight like that everytime, that was Hatton's graduation night.

    In essence, Graham made Hatton fight like he did against Tszyu again and again. The times when this worked were when Hatton was highly motivated. The times it didn't, and he needed something extra in terms of a gameplan or improved boxing, things didn't go so well because I'm not sure they ever honed in on areas to improve. They just let Hatton be Hatton.

    Whereas Hatton has shown in all too brief glimpses he is capable of more. Maybe we are starting to see it with Mayweather, I think this could in time prove my point. But its not as if the evidence was not there for Graham to see.
     
  4. djoc175

    djoc175 Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,892
    0
    Jan 19, 2008
    Mayweathers approach is completely different to that of Graham eg.the body bag vs Floyds method of padwork.Floyd said on 24/7 that Hatton hardly knew how to hit pads when he first took him.
    Mayweather is defensively minded and when you can see his padwork he focuses on head movement and slipping/blocking punches aswell of offence.There was no evidence of this in training videos I have seen involving Graham.The body belt just encouraged them lunging attacks to body and head rather than using a jab to set up attacks-we saw shades of this in the Malignaggi fight though I'm not sure that fight is a good way of measuring his improvement given the way Malignaggi fought.

    To answer the original question,I think Hatton was probably going through the motions a little and needed extra motivation like you said (Tsyzu,castillo are good examples)
     
  5. Beeston Brawler

    Beeston Brawler Comical Ali-egedly Full Member

    46,399
    15
    Jan 9, 2008
    Another factor, as Scurla will no doubt point out.... is the level of opposition he was facing.

    I don't think he is particularly heavy handed...... plenty of the guys in the WBU days were like startled rabbits, and were therefore blown away by his ferocity. In the Phillips and Tackie fights we saw, for the most part, a boxing exhibition in wide points victories - that showed he had the ability to adapt to the opponent, as you point out.

    However, when you are facing the likes of Mayweather, they will study the style in-depth.... not saying the others didn't, but clearly none of them (Tszyu, Mayweather excepted) had the tools to be able to deal with what Hatton brought to the table. This is clearly evident in the Malignaggi fight.... midway through the 2nd stanza you were waiting for the finish - it was over as a contest. Smart cutting off of the ring, feints, the lot - only held up by constant holding by Paulie.

    Floyd sr is definitely the kind to study the opponent, I hear he had Lee Beard working southpaw pads with Hatton very early on - I would very much doubt that was the case for previous encounters with lefties. They did rely on his fitness to bring him through, which is fine for the most part, but there is always someone fitter, no matter who you are!

    It was something Rob McCracken eluded to in an issue of Boxing Monthly, basically saying a typical American trainer is much better than a British one - mainly because they work on technical aspects of boxing.... rather than getting them fit as a flea and telling them to throw a million punches.
     
  6. TFFP

    TFFP The Eskimo

    45,002
    3
    Nov 28, 2007
    I agree with you regarding Mayweather's style and the bodybag a.k.a footrest. I say that because it looked like the footrest I use, you can imagine me on my sofa with my laptop with Graham's bodybag on the floor :cool: It really didn't encourage improvement. We know Hatton can hit the body and throw lunging hooks, how about something more technical? Diversify.

    The motivation thing though, this relates back to what I'm saying. Hatton only had Plan A. And Plan A as a style only results in a great performance if you are 100% motivated, having everything to fight for and as a result are completely sharp. You can't be like that every fight, which is why they needed more from Graham to improve Hatton. Not to turn him into a boxer, because Hatton's strengths work well, but there should have been improvements in areas.

    Compare it to Pacquiao. Not matter who Pacquiao fights, more often than not you can see another piece of the jigsaw coming together. He's not just relying on adrenaline, but you can see what they've been thinking about in the gym.
     
  7. Darni187

    Darni187 Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    15,286
    643
    Nov 13, 2008
    The key for Hatton in this fight is showing the improvements in the ring which he is making under Mayweather Sr in the gym, if any at this late stage of his carrer. Can Hatton adjust if things are not going his way, plan B?

    I do get the feeling that Hatton made the weight better this time round, maybe Mayweather's advise is working about his lifestyle between fights.
     
  8. Strike

    Strike Boxing Addict banned

    3,982
    0
    Sep 14, 2004
    I see...

    :lol:

    Sorry, good post all in all though.
     
  9. TFFP

    TFFP The Eskimo

    45,002
    3
    Nov 28, 2007
    "I said he was nothing but a punching bag against Floyd [Jr], and I don't take that back, you saw it with your own eyes.

    "But now the man's moving his head and he's making the other guy miss while he's punching.

    "I've been very surprised how quick Ricky's learnt. He amazed me, especially being the type of fighter he is. He's a slugger, but he started picking up the new stuff so quick, I couldn't believe it.


    "He hadn't done any of the stuff in his life - jabbing to the body and jabbing to the head, feinting to the body and jabbing to the head, hooking off the jab. He's doing it now."

    "What can you learn from hitting a pillow?" Mayweather asked. "That is what you punch when you're in a bad mood, not what you hit to prepare for the best fighters.

    - Guess who
     
  10. Beeston Brawler

    Beeston Brawler Comical Ali-egedly Full Member

    46,399
    15
    Jan 9, 2008
    I remember him saying afterwards that he felt Hatton was useless..... perhaps Hatton called him bluff and said 'if you think you can do any better....
     
  11. achillesthegreat

    achillesthegreat FORTUNE FAVOURS THE BRAVE Full Member

    37,070
    29
    Jul 21, 2004
    Graham bought into the unstoppable Hatton hype just like Hatton did. It's your trainers job to play devils advocate, give you some perspective etc Graham didn't do that. Graham got Hatton in great shape and Kayes made Hatton extremely strong. However this totally overlooked what Hatton was missing - a sense of range, timing, defence, combinations, not continously hugging, a jab, gameplan, accuracy etc

    Graham betrayed the sweet science. Hatton is a physical specimen - quick feet, strong, powerful and with a strong mind.

    Graham would look at Hattons record and say he lost once and justify everything else that went wrong. He never looked at Hatton stop body punching, getting hit too much etc

    Dare I say it, Hatton was a better fighter technically when he was an amateur. Hatton looked to get worse. His technique became horrible as his hands dropped and he was jumping all over the place.

    When Hatton trained and ripped that belt he got in great shape but like I said earlier - where was the science? Every shot was woefully inaccurate cos he couldn't miss.

    Hatton is naturally an ferocious fighter. Mayweather is trying to add science. I only fear that Hatton's nature will overcome his nurture. I hope by now Mayweathers nurturing has overcome Hattons natural full steam ahead approach.
     
  12. trotter

    trotter Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,762
    2
    Apr 18, 2008
    Graham told Hatton in a number of fights to cool it, to get back to his boxing

    Hatton didn't listen


    However, while I think Hatton became much more 'streetwise' in the ring after Tszyu (Castillo in particular being a great, sharp, crafty performance), it looked like he wasn't working much on technique

    Not surprising given that his camps were almost exclusively dedicated to dropping weight and getting fit after 3-4 months of doing nothing

    So in many ways I don't think you can lay the blame on Graham, Hatton himself got complacent until the Floyd rude awakening


    When you look at how Pacquaio has studied the craft and developed in recent years, it just shows what can be done with particularly good raw ingredients, like Hatton had
     
  13. SouthpawSlayer

    SouthpawSlayer Im coming for you Full Member

    16,351
    2
    Sep 6, 2008
    has anyone ever considered that with the help of mayweather hatton could actually leave himself more vulnerable, i have seen hatton working the pads with mayweather and he seems way more open when throwing the jab as he is trying to get too much speed behind it and his right hand tends to float away from the face area, im sure as soon as hatton gets rocked he will revert back to his original style, over the last month hatton has gone on about his size difference but i think he is gonna try and box pac to start off with use his foot and hand speed that he has been raving about but this will really play into pacs hands, hatton needs to rush pac and he needs to be able to work hard for 12 rounds like he did against collazo (even though i thought he lost) although hatton showed great balls in that fight, if graham was more of a fitness coach then perhaps hatton would of been better off with graham for this fight, thats assuming he is not in as good shape as we all know pacs workrate is second to none
     
  14. achillesthegreat

    achillesthegreat FORTUNE FAVOURS THE BRAVE Full Member

    37,070
    29
    Jul 21, 2004
    hattons become a better technical boxer under floyd but his technique hasn't improved at all, not yet anyway.
     
  15. Tuffnutz

    Tuffnutz ESB 2002 Club Full Member

    6,433
    2
    Jul 19, 2004
    :gayfight