splitting the divisions in half, and speaking head-2-head not resume, who do you think the top 10 fighters under 147, and over 147 are? (active only) here's mine 147 and under.. 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Juan Manuel Marquez 3. Nonito Donaire 4. Miguel Cotto 5. Israel Vasquez 6. Rafael Marquez 7. Juanma Lopez 8. Shane Mosley 9. Antonio Margarito 10. Vic Darchinyan honorable mentions - Ricky Hatton, Andre Berto, Chris John, Juan Diaz, Timothy Bradley over 147... 1. Chad Dawson happy) 2. Bernard Hopkins 3. Joe Calzaghe 4. Vitali Klitchsko 5. David Haye 6. Wladamir Klitchsko 7. Lucian Bute 8. Mikkel Kessler 9. Sergio Martinez 10.Sergiy Dzinziruk honorable mentions - Andre Dirrell, Arthur Abraham, Tomasz Adamek, Alfredo Angulo, Enzo Maceriaonellli [howeva you spell that ****] so lets see 'em....
So are you saying Chad Dawson beats anyone over 147...and Manny beats anyone under? Im a tad befuddled at what you want.
hmm......you just confused me, and now that i think about it i'm confused myself at what i wanted too but ight i mean: lets say if P4P rankings were based off of just that, who's the best fighter pound for pound, and not off of who beat who.....that make since? thats it, i'm not saying Chad Dawson would beat Vitali, or Bernard would beat Haye, or Calzaghe would beat Wlad i mean i think Chad's a better fighter then Vitali, and Bernards the better fighter then Haye, and i think Calzaghes the better fighter then Wlad does that make since? basically just comparing all the fighters talents, attributes, etc... instead of comparing fighters resumes
well i'm not gonna argue that because it would obviously be a waste of a time.....but i'll leave it at this "no, Dawson would KO Joe"
Donaire is ridiculously high. He did not impress me greatly last time out, certainly not to suggest he deserves this sort of lofty ranking. Dawson the best fighter above 147? He's looked fragile on a number of occasions. Haye and Wlad, not to mention Calzaghe have displayed far greater dominance in their performances without even thinking about resume.
i agree, but one fight doesn't exactly dissaprove how great he looked in his others, in terms, of speed, power, skill, defense, ring generalship etc. he's one of the most complete fighters in the world, very few more complete then him Haye and Wlad also have bad chins.........and neither are as skilled as Dawson, and i've already touched on my thoughts on Calzaghe
IF Chuck Norris lift his fingers, all of them will be ktfo in just a glimpse. Seriously I don't get the point...
Wlad has a bad chin but he's been more dominant in his overall performance. Chad Dawson was wobbling like a drunk against Glen Johnson and only just pulled out a decision. Same against Adamek he was hurt badly. This is why I find it difficult to see how he's supposed to be better than Calzaghe, or Wlad who hasn't been hurt or even hit for a long time. He looks fragile. Sven Ottke beat Glen Johnson more convincingly.
Yeah, I don't get it either... It says "head to head" and yet, if you look at this ridiculous list, the #9 guy would KO absolutely everyone on this list, except possibly the #8 guy:huh And the #1 guy couldn't beat the #4, possibly #8, and die in the ring against the #9 guy.:huh Is this some attempt at a pound for pound list?:huh 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Juan Manuel Marquez 3. Nonito Donaire 4. Miguel Cotto 5. Israel Vasquez 6. Rafael Marquez 7. Juanma Lopez 8. Shane Mosley 9. Antonio Margarito 10. Vic Darchinyan
