Hearn/Joshua and Finkel/Wilder comically overplayed their hands

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Redbeard7, Dec 23, 2023.


  1. Redbeard7

    Redbeard7 Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,168
    2,206
    Oct 9, 2022
    Back in 2018/2019 Joshua and Wilder held all four of the sanctioning body belts and were undefeated with over 60 wins combined with 60+ KO's. Their fight would have been for the undisputed championship (setting aside Fury's claim to the lineal title) and one of the biggest money fights in heavyweight history, perhaps the biggest. The plan on both sides followed the Mayweather-Pacquiao model; let the superfight "marinate" and take seemingly less dangerous fights in the meantime. Build a one-hundred million dollar payday into a four-hundred million dollar payday.

    Five or so years later Joshua and Wilder haven't fought, they have three losses apiece and there is comparatively minimal demand for a fight between them. Both men were eliminated from the title picture by Usyk and Fury respectively, who are scheduled to fight for the undisputed championship in a matter of months. The endless cycle of rematches with A-side advantage couldn't ultimately save Joshua or Wilder.

    Joshua suffered arguably the most humiliating defeat in heavyweight history, getting bounced off the canvas four times before quitting in seven rounds against the fattest contender since Tony Galento. He was later soundly outboxed twice by Usyk, becoming the first SHW with elite credentials to lose twice (and by clear margins) to a former cruiserweight. But instead of making the fight with Wilder ageing and inactive, 38 years old with two KO defeats in his last three fights (and despite Hearn claiming pre-Whyte/Helenius that the Wilder fight was "locked in" for December 2023), Hearn/Joshua opted for a series of rehabilitation fights against less dangerous opponents. As a consequence of these delaying tactics, a very faded Wilder got dominated by Parker and Hearn/Joshua now find themselves bereft of superfights, with the Wilder and Fury fights unlikely (Joshua’s main rivals from mid 2017 to mid 2021) and not nearly what they were financially in any case. But perhaps the Ngannou fight is there for them if they don't fancy Hrgovic for the apparently soon to be vacant IBF. Another irony: If Joshua had fought and beat Wilder back in 2018 or even later, he would have probably got fights with Fury too. And Fury wouldn’t have been able to “steal” the Wilder fights from him.

    Wilder escaped with a controversial draw in the first fight against Fury and was brutalised in the second and third fights. Being four years older than Joshua, time wasn't on Wilder's side. Coming off virtually 26 months of inactivity, a 38 year old Wilder found himself unable to pull the trigger in a shameful Malik Scott-esque performance, dominated over 12 rounds by 5/1 underdog Parker. Wilder is washed up and should retire.

    This saga should serve as an example to other fighters and promoters going forward as to how "marination" can backfire spectacularly, especially at heavyweight. Their extreme greed, overconfidence and cynicism came back to bite them.
     
    Last edited: Jan 16, 2024
  2. Trafford

    Trafford Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,935
    2,834
    Sep 29, 2018
    Hearn/AJ did just fine without Wilder. Wilder turned down $100m on the day so of Al Haymon not wanting to lose his fighter to another platform that was giving him sleepless nights.

    in years to come Wilder will sue Haymon and maybe even Finkel for the advice they gave. AJ fought the much bigger challenge in Usyk twice
     
    BlackDog, lobk, Jolly Roger and 2 others like this.
  3. Redbeard7

    Redbeard7 Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,168
    2,206
    Oct 9, 2022
    "AJ fought the much bigger challenge in Usyk twice"

    ???

    How is fighting "the much bigger challenge" and getting beaten twice (three times in total) for a fraction of the money good management?

    It's a catastrophic blunder on both sides. Joshua saying "I'll still fight Wilder" lol.
     
    Jackman65 likes this.
  4. KINGWILDER

    KINGWILDER Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,789
    2,595
    May 11, 2023
    The point on marination is spot on.

    It’s hilarious that you have to be spend a significant proportion of the post hating on AJ though. Can you never admit you were wrong?

    AJ’s career and legacy is far greater than Wilder’s - I don’t think there’s much debating this anymore. You can bang on about the Ruiz fight all you want - truth is a guy Joshua beat convincingly just beat Wilder 12-0. You can use ring rust and age as an excuse, the truth is Wilder is overrated and not nearly as good as you thought. Nothing wrong with being off on fighters.
     
  5. Brighton bomber

    Brighton bomber Loyal Member Full Member

    31,125
    28,943
    Apr 4, 2005
    One of the first times I'll agree with you Redbeard. No reason why the fight couldn't of happened last night it was mooted for December all year long and then they pulled a bait and switch and we got Wilder/Parker and Joshua/Wallin instead which lets be honest isn't why we were looking forward to the proposed December card in Saudi Arabia. I guess that's why they had to come up with that expensive promo.

    They definitely overplayed their hands and all involved are to blame. Joshua/Wilder for all the titles would have definitively been the biggest fight of this era without a doubt which is why DAZN were offering outrageous money for Wilder to face Breazeale and then Joshua, but Wilder ducked the fight, perhaps to marinate it as that seems to be a Haymon method of business and then Hearn the idiot when he finally has Wilder amenable to a Joshua fight does the same damn thing and thinks he can squeeze and extra fight between and milk the boxing fans of another PPV payday.

    They should have learned from the Fury/Ngannou fight where that too almost ended up backfiring when instead of giving us Fury/Usyk in December as proposed for most of the year then pushed it back and gave us Fury almost losing to a novice boxer.

    Fury/Usyk needs to happen next, no more tune ups or that payday will also be going down the drain.
     
    KO KIDD, UmarIFLUmar, Holler and 4 others like this.
  6. ashishwarrior

    ashishwarrior I'm vital ! Full Member

    34,379
    11,863
    Apr 19, 2010
    Wilder thinking them belt carrying purse
    Are there to be collected
    You've just been on and under card
    Promoted by fwank
    Played to the uk time
    America is where it's at though
    Wilder is now an uncard fighter which his ego wont allow
    Put him in with big baby
    He wont take them fights
    Wilder as been found out
    50 fights in
    Americwar good at rolling turns in glitter then over valuing it
     
  7. MorvidusStyle

    MorvidusStyle Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,402
    5,573
    Jul 11, 2017
    It's incredible people defend AJ and Hearn still. True mugs, as the 'brits' say.

    There are even people gushing over AJ's win against Wallin, or surprised that it wasn't competitive. How stupid are you people? Did you actually think they picked Wallin because he was a dangerous fight? He's one of the lightest punching SHW's out there. They picked him because they were avoiding Fury and Wilder and wanted a relatively safe 'name' fighter to justify the big event. Obviously people were cheering for an upset, but that doesn't mean he was a truly dangerous opponent.

    Fury handled him easily as far as winning the rounds went, and was blinded with an incredible cut that was simply a lucky punch.

    So now AJ gets another title shot probably, off the back of what? Losing to Usyk twice then fighting 'tune-ups' and Wallin, who's beaten nobody. All the fans will be out celebrating their three-time champion!

    It's also clearly lost on people that Wilder is 38 years old. Can you count past ten? Or are you stuck at single digits like Wilder and AJ? Because in no sport is 38 not 'past it'. I don't care about Wilder, in fact I despise him and I enjoy the fact he lost. But don't pretend he's in his early 30s still and this Wilder was the one Fury beat and AJ ducked for years. Wilder relies on speed and explosiveness and that declines rapidly in middle-age.

    Also, if clowns actually believe anybody offered anyone 100 million dollars for a fight and it was turned down, wtf planet are you living on. Finkel would literally do everything in his power to make Wilder take that offer if it was real.
     
    Redbeard7, MarkusFlorez99 and MrPook like this.
  8. BlackDog

    BlackDog Active Member Full Member

    918
    1,286
    Sep 4, 2023
    Pls Shut up...
    Wilder admit himself that he dont take this massive offer... This was official offer from DAZN...
    Even Finkiel admit it.

    This Joshua and Hearn haters are just stupid af...

    You even try change history, disregard facts and even words from boxers just to still have platform for hate...

    Just Shut up. Go read and learn how to admit that You were wrong...
     
    lobk, Mod-Mania and Trafford like this.
  9. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    79,882
    20,451
    Sep 15, 2009
    Fight marination is the worst thing to happen to boxing.

    The fights take place after the primes, lots of soft touches in between and all against the fans wishes.

    It's like a broken record now but we all know where this happens and where it doesn't.
     
    Holler and KINGWILDER like this.
  10. KINGWILDER

    KINGWILDER Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,789
    2,595
    May 11, 2023
    So you single out AJ fans while failing to acknowledge Fury fans have been claiming Wallin will beat AJ for months. Now AJ smokes him, in far easier fashion than Fury beat him, Wallin is rubbish. It’s typical, and just shows people will discredit anyone when they can no longer strengthen their agenda.

    I don’t blame Joshua and Hearn entirely, both teams are at fault.

    You highlight Wilder’s age but heavyweights fight in much longer than other guys (look at Wlad and Foreman). Also by your own logic Fury’s and Wilder’s biggest wins were against guys who were totally past it then.

    Truth is Wilder lost due to multiple factors including his age, inactivity, damage taken from the Fury fights, being completely out smarted, not having any footwork, and just generally being overrated. He’s not had one win against a legit top ten guy who was in their prime. The problems Parker gave him last night would still have been problems in his prime.

    You can critique AJ all you want, truth is he’s beaten far more top contenders than Wilder. He may have been overrated, was steered clear of Wilder in 2018 (I agree with you here), but at least he wasn’t fed absolute c/d level journeyman his whole career.
     
  11. Ted Stickles

    Ted Stickles Boxing Addict Full Member

    6,244
    2,176
    Jun 24, 2007
    If boxing history proves anything , it is NEVER a good idea to announce a fight while fighters have fights to get through first. It actually motivates the opponents to be the spoiler.
     
    VBOX, Joeywill, Holler and 1 other person like this.
  12. Trafford

    Trafford Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,935
    2,834
    Sep 29, 2018
    He got more for Usyk 2 than he would have for the original Wilder fights in 2018. He never ducked.

    it wasn’t til the PBC money dried up and Saudi had the funds to appease wilder that he turned up to the negotiating table.
     
    KINGWILDER likes this.
  13. Boxing Gloves

    Boxing Gloves Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,426
    1,451
    Jul 19, 2004
    I mean from a fan perspective its far from comical because its another great fight we've missed out on. Shame that we are the ones that lose out due to boxers and promoters greed.
     
  14. Trafford

    Trafford Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,935
    2,834
    Sep 29, 2018
    This particular fight was not marination. It was a case of one platform putting up funds and the other not wanting their guy on said platform.

    PBC managed to get Wilder to take fights on their platform. The same thing they did with Spence, Gervonta etc. fighters will eventually learn activity and not listening to the PBC nonsense is the best option
     
  15. deadACE

    deadACE Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,203
    979
    Apr 13, 2014
    Joshua v Wilder wasn't for the titles last night, that fight is largely insignificant outside of bragging rights and shuts up all the ducking talk. We would have preferred that fight obviously.

    Joshua makes till in any fight. Hearn possibly lost out not Joshua tho. Wilder moves out of the title elminator and insert whoever next.
     
    Last edited: Dec 24, 2023