Heavyweight ranking's after Saturday

Why are people leaving David Price off their top 30 lists?

 

He hasn't fought anybody.

 

I'd be interested in hearing how you have Chisora ahead of Helenius and Fury.

In each case, would that be based on accomplishment or head-to-head ?

 

There definitely is a valid argument to rank him below Helenius and Fury.

I'm ranking him above because of his good performance yesterday. Above Helenius basically because I scored that fight clearly for Chisora. And that fight, plus his performance against #1 Vitali, puts him above Fury.

However, that is debatable and I might change it, depending on other arguments.

 

Once the klits retire eddie chambers will be the top champ in the hw division

 

I would call that a bit of an understatement.

Based on one performance ?

One where he lost 10-2 or 11-1 to an injured man old enough to be his dad ?

A gutsier performance than most of Vitali's previous victims, but it should be kept in perspective.

Helenius has a much stronger resume, and undefeated Tyson's clear win over Chisora is better than anything Chisora (1-4 in his last three outings) has managed so far.

These matters are subjective, but IMO, Chisora is far too high on your list.

Haye, Chambers, Povetkin, Adamek and Dimitrenko would all be easy to justify above him. Probably others too.

 

Yeah, maybe in Britardia.

 

I won't rate Chambers or Mormeck cause they haven't fought in over a year. Haye is in there as it doesn't look like he'll stay retired.

1. Wlad Klitschko
2. Vitali Klitschko
3. Povetkin
4. Haye
5. Thompson
6. Chisora
7. Helenius
8. Adamek
9. Arreola
10. Pulev
11. Huck
12. Chagaev
13. Dimitrenko
14. Fury
15. Ustinov
16. Boytsov
17. Solis
18. Lawrence
19. Stiverne
20. Mitchell

 

Chisora shouldn't be in the top ten. Heart is not enough to get it done.

- And hard to know where to put Solis, since he really WAS injured in his last fight.

Mitchell should be up there with Chagaev & Dimintrenko.

Boytsov, as much as I like him, has done NOTHING to crack the top 30. Same fpr Wilder, even though I think he may be the future champ.

 

big guy price from liverpool wil b knocking just shortly

 

Boystov has at least beaten Pala (better than any of Mitchell's wins). And he certainly moves alot better than Mitchell.

I was skeptical about Chisora but he confirmed enough last night for me to put him ahead of Adamek and Helenius.

 

you mean the guy who lost handily to a green Povetkin?

 

Even if that's true how the hell do you justify a top 10 ranking? Wins over Harrison and Ruiz earn him that? Haye's mouth have people ranking him top 10, he needs to accomplish something for that designation. Ditto Chambers who hasnt done anything for like 2 years