I'd favor Manny. Manny would have problems early because he's never faced anyone faster than himself, but then again Manny is a helluva lot faster, and more skilled than Jose Luis Ramirez. I think Manny's aggression would see him win a decision.
Damn those who pick camacho are either idiots or puerto ricans. Pacquiao would beat camacho, not even on the same level of greatness. However, Pacquiao vs. any past fighter, pacquiao always loses just like most. It is just the way people think.
In all fairness to Pac, he has done things as well that no other before him has done. Koed fighters no one else has in fashions no one else has done.
Not even Tito at 147 walked Hector down and you expect lil Manny at 135 to do it...against a prime Hector? not even Chavez or Rosario could do it but you expect Manny to? it doesnt make sense.
you're discrediting manny's win against oscar but crediting pbf's win over jmm.. nice logic there buddy.
they're all "weight-drained", "past prime", "non-black", "over-the-hill", "terminally ill", "robbed", "damaged goods". back in my day, when we used to walk 5 miles uphill thru 8 inches of snow just to watch hector camacho, boxers research their opponent's background/medical history/family background for years before making a match just to make sure the said opponent is fighting at his prime with no distractions.
sorry to ruin your idea of a camacho party... who was hector fighting at 135 that makes you think he could beat pac there? irleis perez, greg coverson, melvin paul. all undefeated when camacho faced them but not exactly household names. pac was fighting morales, barera, and marquez just under 135, beating them. you will notice also pac has improved on his speed and power in moving up to welter. something you cannot say for marquez. you are wrong when you say floyd beat the same guy pac had competitive fights with. marquez against floyd was 12 pounds north of the one who faught pac. with those 12 pounds, marquez didn't cary his speed or power with him. pac didn't stick around long at 135, yall can practically make up anything you want about him at that weight. so pretend all you like. after pac fights cotto, you won't be able to catch him except in pretend matchups at pretend weights. hey i'm a camacho fan. the guy was busy. pac is faster, would starch him.
Manny is only good in REALITY not FANTASY fights. That is where Floyd rules all, fantasy fights, so much so that his fans don't even see a need to fight anyone in the entire welterweight division because all fights are foregone conclusions........therefore we have the respective winners of their realms: Pacqauiao: Champ in Reality (but loses all possible fantasy match ups of course!) Mayweather: Champ in Fantasy (no need to fight welters he would beat them)