Higher ATG Ranking: Juan Manuel Marquez or Manny Pacquiao?

i didnt know catchweights were official divisions? pac man is a great fighter but every title he or any fighter won whilst fighting at catchweight should be null and voided,

to the answer the question i think marquez, just! if for anything the way he ko'd pac man in his last fight

 

Marquez.

 

agree pac mans resume is abit better, but those wins against jmm dnt show the true picture of the fights, also i think the longevity of jmm career adds a few points, i mean p4p number 2 or 3 at 40 is alomost unheard of

 

Agreed. And didnt he become a lightweight "champion" by beating David Diaz. How about how many weights did he actually unify, not cherrypick the weakest trinket holder?

 

he he he ... pac>>>>>>floyd in resume and you say marquez>>>>>pac? he he he

 

Pacquiao.

i'd like to see Marquez pass through these guys. well maybe Hatton.

- Erik Morales x2
- Oscar De La Hoya
- Ricky Hatton
- Miguel Cotto
- Antonio Margarito
- Shane Mosley

add in Clottey

 

Manny P has the better resume.

Marquez always had Manny's number, though.

Oh, and I love how you list Bradley and Marquez x2 on Manny's record, when Manny officially lost to Bradley.
I thought Manny lost all the fights to Marquez.

 

It is close, to vote now I would say Manny,however if JMM gets a clear win over Bradley and keeps going it could change.
Also hard to say how Pac will end his Career,will he step back up and fight someone huge again or are the days of taking the best fights over for him.

 

pacquiao did too many good things early in his career and marquez bloomed too late.

pacquiao for me

 

I don't know why people keep on forgetting that Pac has 4 Lineal championships, even 3 lineals is really rare in boxing, how much mores so for 4 lineal championships?

 

He does?? That's hella impressive. Which divisions?

 

The 165 pound Margarito that Manny destroyed would have stopped Marquez in 7 .

Marquez does not have the speed that Manny had to evade Margaritos relentless attack .


Eventually somewhere in the fight Marquez will trade with Antonio , to show hes has just as much as heart as he do and thats were Marquez demise will begin .