I think you need to refresh your memory and hit the tapes again if you think Gavilan had better footwork than Napoles. Napoles had some of the best, most balanced footwork I've ever seen, and his ability to change up the pace on the drop of a dime was great to watch. Also, while Gavilan had a nice jab, Napoles had a more accurate and more efficient one, because he wouldn't get as easily tagged in return due to his slickness on defense. He had the better defense than Gavilan as well.
For **** sake I was going to stay away from the forum for a while and this thread brought me right back in. Gavilan is my favorite fighter bar none. A few years back I met a Cuban family in Miami's Calle Ocho who gifted me with a picture taken with Gavilan, their father, and then presidential candidate Eduardo Chibas in the "El Floridita" night club in Havana, year 1951. My interest in Gavilan began there and continues today. I agree with everything you say Pea, especially about his versatility and fluidity, not only in movement but in ring versatility. The four fights I have (Buker, Turner, Bratton II, Janiro II) showcase his ability to play the boxer, the preasure fighter, and the brawler- and to move fluidly between these styles depending on what a fight or an opponent dictated. His fight with Buker is a great one to see. Its a young and impressive Gavilan.
This is the interview. It was his last. Its in Spanish and the audio is bad but its interesting anyways. I will do a better translation later, but for the most part he is talking about his career, his winning belts, etc. He has a great memory for dates, the round that he KO'd this fighter or that fighter- even at this age, amazing really. He is also asked who was his hardest fight- his response is Jacky Berg from England, and Tony Canzoneri. Asked who the toughest Cuban he ever fought was, he responds Carlito Blanco and Johnny Cruz. [yt]p6_jhae6sSw[/yt]
I have a friend in his mid 80's who is one of my best boxing buddies. This guy saw Marciano, Robinson, and many other legends live. He talks about Kid Gavilin a lot; he thinks very highly of him.
I would also argue that what in on youtube is not the best Gavilan (although the fights Pea mentioned in the beggining of the thread are better than what was on youtube of him before).
Would you say he looked better against Buker than the fights I mentioned? And just so everyone knows, I was blazed off my mind when I made this thread. Damn I can write pretty good when high.
He looks younger and fresher in the Buker fight. Maybe not as refined, yet his reflexes are faster and he is obviously a younger man. Raging B(_)ll when he sent it to me, described Gavilan as being in his absolute prime or something to that effect. In the Turner fight, he faces a fighter in his own mold. SRL made an anology to his match with Benitez when he entered the ring to see what he called a mirror image of himself. The Janiro fight is a good one as well, with Gavilan playing more of the boxer role. By the way, I'm thinking of ordering some Napoles. Your high on him and from what I have seen he was great. I watched the Monzon fight last night, he was clearly outsized.
I don't care to watch his MW fights with guys like Monzon. He's nowhere near his best and far too outsized, yet holds his own for a while anyway. From 135-147 is where he was a true beast. His fights with Cokes display his full ability at WW, as well as his fight with Griffith, though I've not seen it and Griffith was said to not be at his best. He's said to be even better at LW and JWW though.