Hopkins, Pac, DLH, RJJ and FLoyd in same ATG vicinity.

discount oscar from that list , I cant name an elite fighter he beat at his peak. hes a HOF but not an ATG

 

Floyd and Pac are levels above those other fighters you listed!!

 

Oscar doesn't belong.

It would be a copmletely different ball game if it was a beauty contest though.

 

I agree, and Oscar DOES belong imo


-I reread I missed the vicinity part. Yeah Hops-RJJ-Floyd-Pac are the top of the ATG class where Oscar-Wright-Trinidad-Forrest are just a bit below. Not by much though

 

You're thinking with your dick. This is dangerous.

 

Just stating my opinion as well, Oscar is not up there w/ atg's ... while a good boxer he failed to capitalize too many times.

Now if we are talking Sexy Sergio & Oscar, then we can rank them ATG beauty pagents.

 

thumbsup
Yes last time I thought with my dick I ended up with a 24-hour errection. :admin

 

He looks better than Hollywood A-listers. What a handsome man.

 

floyd skills might be ATG but his resume doesnt even come close to ray leonards, ali, pac, hopkins, ray robinson, dlh fought the best and lost but he still fought the best.

 

Evander Holyfield

 

thats why I added the second part. I was indeed thinking with my dick. It happens.

 

He got beat up one too many times. Vargas is considered his sweetest win, but he even finds a way to get lost and give away some rounds in there.

 

I'm OK with this thread. First impulse was to say Oscar doesn't quite make it into this group, but I suppose the fact he clearly deserved the decisions over Trinidad and in the second Mosley fight mean he can't be all that far behind Floyd, considering Floyd has ZERO wins as good as those two.

I still have Floyd higher than him because I think Floyd has only lost one fight, vs JLC, which he avenged, whereas I thought Oscar lost to both Quartey and Whitaker by a point each time, plus I think the sfw Floyd was probably a marginally better fighter than the lw/lww Oscar.

Anyway, I agree that those five are the standouts of the era, and this is my order:


Pacquiao

Hopkins/Jones (leaning more towards Hopkins being ahead of Jones these days)





Mayweather
De La Hoya