This is not a fight I would bet any money on. Either guy could win, and it would possibly be an ATG technical battle. I give Hopkins the edge. Toney is clearly better in close, but I don't think that Hopkins would play that game with him.
Big Bhops fan here, but Toney could be abit more explosive and was just as crafty as Hopkins. Ill have to go with Toney. He did everything just abit better than Hopkins and thats cuz Toney isnt a very tall guy either.