"the problem i have with both decisions, is that both guys fought as though they knew they were going to get the nod. They just weren't busy enough" Fair enough Sandman, but not everyone has to fight like Henry Armstrong to get the nod; I'll always appreciate quality, precision work over a human thrashing machine. Foley fought well off the counter, although I do think Chan posed some questions for him and the jury is still out, and managed to land enough scoring shots, where as James threw plenty but not enough were landing in the scoring area. I don't think I have ever seen anyone anywhere near as tough as Chan though - he has my undying respect