How can Floyd be regarded #1 at 147 (some claim he is P4P) if he has not fought ...

atsch lineage doesnt come from Ring magazine

 

Linear champion, and by all means he is the undisputed champ, since Cory Spinks unified, then Zab beat him, then Baldomir and Floyd beat the last two undisputed champions, so how could he not be number 1?

 

Thats what I just said desperado.

 

Undisputed does not mean linear desperado.

 

I didn't say it did king ****! I am saying that it is seperate, and that Floyd is both.

 

Well go on and explain his linealness then your highness.

 

:good

 

Then where are you getting Floyd's linealness?

Cat got your toungs?

 

Floydian slips or False hopes?

 

http://cyberboxingzone.com/boxing/welter.htm


had to dig that up.....it stops at 2003 with spinks...zab beat spinks....baldomir beat zab...pbf beat baldomir.....

 

Um excuse me but your Floydian slippin again just as Sugarandgold and jamkiller did because you have just regressed to the Ring linealism which is not true linealism cause sugar never beat Trinny.

 

See how they picked their own lineal champions throughout the weight classes after 2000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Ring_world_champions

It kind of like why Hopkins shouldnt be considered Ring champ over the true lineal champ Erdei

 

shane shouldnt have been considered lineal after beating dlh....but lineal starts over when the titles are unified....i believe mayorga unified the wba with forrest's wbc belt...then spinks unified those with his ibf belt....then thats where the zab beat spinks baldomir beat zab and pbf beat baldomir comes into play

 

I know what your saying and it is probably closer to lineal than the other Ring picks but still I think that I would have returned it to Whitiker (who was robbed against La Hoya) after Trinny moved up. I cant remember who the other top welters of the time were.

 

yea i think whitaker was robbed also but i can only go by what the decisions actually were....and whitaker most likely would have retired lineal champ...but then the lineage gets started over when the titles are unified