How can u rank Floyd higher all-time p4p when Pac has better resume & achievements?

Pac has surpassed PBF legacy wise, although neither are done yet.

 

Point 1. No, I tried to keep the debate on point. Going on with the Calzaghe angle gives you an opportunity to respond to point 1 without actually answering anything(Like you did here).You got me to come off point last night. You wont today. We will try again.

How can you rank Lopez higher all-time P4P when Mosley has better resume and achievement.


Mosley has a better resume than Lopez. Mosley has better weight-jumping feats than Lopez. And they have never fought. No other factors are needed to take into account in this one.

"I arrived at this hypothesis by examining several key factors. Factor one was resume. Resume is a list of all the fighters that the boxer in question has ever fought. The second factor is achievements, such as number of titles won and number of weight divisions competed in. Now when these two factors go in one fighter's favour, there is no need to move on to further factors of peripheral importance...."


Would that statement be watertight, and no need for "Peripheral factors"? No. And you went on to 'C' when compiling your list. Why?

Let's stay with Point 1 untill we reach a conclusion and move forward. We can come back to the other points.

 

Pick a hole in the rating system?. You mean the one i have praised about a dozen times in this thread?

It's how you pick and choose what one's to drop to suit your argument that im having trouble understanding. Not the system.

I'll be back the morn, no rush.

 

i see pac and pbf in a p4p race.both beat hatton and odh.id like to see how good pbf looks against jmm.see if he can destroy a man pac struggles with.pac never struggled against hatton or odh(odh was alot better at 154) but still.both multiple champs in hella weight classes.both have beatn some great fighters.

the real answer will be the winnner of the fight.

 

NOT BY BUSINESS STANDARDS..MAYWEATHER-DE LA HOYA WAS MUCH BIGGER THAN A PAC-FLOYD FIGHT EVEN RIGHT NOW...OSCAR IS STILL THE PPV KING AND HE BRINGS MORE MONEY TO THE TABLE THAN MANNY AND PAC COMBINED JUSS ABOUT!:deal

 

co-sign...lets hope arum don't fuk it all up!

 

i dont believe so. pac is fighting bigger guys while floyd is fighting smaller fighters. some have duran above leanord all time because he was the person moving up and challenging himself. i dont think it is enough for floyd to beat pac to be above him all time. he needs to clear out his division.

 

Ya I have to agree pac has some losses though but at both fighters peak pac is way more dominant. Hes jumping weights and destroying guys. He also takes all the toughest fights and provides much more excitement.

 

Pac has not beaten anyone but Arum's stable of fighters, and he is called great by his fans lol. He beat a shot dlh, and the Hatton victory was a good win despite criticism of Hatton. His resume is filled with names only. Guys who were fighting for like 13 years already, and fighting top comp while Pac toiled with bums before he fought Barrera. Had Pac received a proper 10 count against Hussein, Hussein would've added another loss to Pac's record. Pac does nothing better than Floyd, and he has no Floyd type fighter on his resume, and until he beats Floyd, he will always be beneath Floyd.