How could one possibly say Pacquaio resume is better than Mayweather

you cant really say that Corrales is up there man not sure if he is an ATG but he was in his prime and undefeated and was thrashing everybody in front of him

 

well he is floyd's best win, i give you that.

 

Dont give me that give that to Floyd he is the one who took that fight and dissected him like a lab rat

 

Losses full well affect your ATG standing and LEGACY.
Do they however affect your resume? Or is your resume just who you have beaten?

 

mayweather groupies are the worst **** ever!!!

 

I do not feel that losses will effect your legacy look at Jones Jr and Holyfield those guys are on lossing streaks often but will still both go down as ATGs and HOFers based on who they did beat.

 

It's pretty close, but I give Pac the edge currently because his wins over MAB and EM trump anything Floyd has yet done.

However, Floyd has an excellent chance to pull ahead in my book as he is potentially alot farther away from being finished than is Pac. The way Floyd fights and takes care of himself between fights, he could end up goin' long a la' Hopkins and Big George, if he wants to. Pac? Not so much...

Finally, let me get on record sayin' that any version of Floyd beats any version of Pac and at any point in their careers.

It's all pretty much a matter of opinion, but there's my .02

 

ok. atsch

 

they do affect your legacy in most cases, i agree they don't in them cases

 

It depends. If you're beaten past your best, by another great fighter, or in a situation where you're seriously weight drained and it shows in the fight, (say if for example you're KO'd after coming in looking like a skeleton and your next fight is 3 weight classes higher) then I don't hold those losses against a fighter.

That Roy Jones lost to Danny Green doesn't wipe out his greatness. That Foreman and Frazier lost to Ali doesn't mean that they don't deserve to be recognized as a top 10 heavyweights. Etc.

 

He also has more losses...

 

actually, they are the ****. they can make certain fighters unshot and undamaged when they want it after labeling them shot before. they can also make a hyped-quitter into a young and hungry lion.

 

severity depends on the circumstance....what stage of the fighters career the loss happened, who the opponent is or how the fighter lost.

 

i agree
good answers

 

Pac beating Barerra > Floyd entire career

Heck...Pac knocking Morales down > Floyd entire career / even Floyd will agree as he was seen jumping for joy