How did you all score the Jose luis Castillo vs. Floyd mayweather Jr. 1 fight?

any neutral scores the fight for castillo, simple as that.

 

I have it exactly the same :good

 

40 have tried but only one succeeded.

Castillo won that fight.

 

So lets get this straight a Mexican-American scores it to Mayweather, but every Mayweather hater scores it to Castillo, interesting :yep

 

Mayweather by a point. But I wouldn't argue with a draw. Like all close bouts...it's essential to watch with the volume down.

 

No, neutral fans scored it for Castillo.

 

JLC won the fight. Just like JMM won the 2nd fight against PAC, close but a clear win.

 

:deal

 

I agree with James Toney. Floyd lost.

 

Mayweather won a very close fight. Rematch needed to happen and thank god it did.

 

I had it 7-5 or 8-4 Castillo

 

114-112 Assweather.

Sorry fellas but I watched this fight 500 times, and the more I watch the more I notice, alot of Castillo's flurries, the ones that had the announcers panties getting wet, and the the crowd freaking out, didn't land alot.

Obviously Castillo was more active, but from watching the fight, NOT GOING BY PUNCHSTATS, what I saw was Floyd being the more accurate puncher (for the most part) and Castillo throwing alot, but barely landing truely legit punches. Alot of Castillo's "landed punches" were alot of the time counted, when is glove barely touched ****weather's ear or , landed on his arms. To me that isn't legit landed punces. Good strategy for a fighter like shitweather, but I can't score it.

Bring on the pain.

 

just watched it and i had 2 scores

115-113 castillo where every close or possible round i gave to mayweather

117-113 castillo where i scored it on who ACTUALLY won the round

i rewatch the key rounds and i just can't possibly give it to mayweather. you don't win a round with a jab and a run. body punches count and castillo scored TONS of sneaky, heavy body punches throughout. if watching head hunting only, than you give it to mayweather but including the body castillo roughed him up and won it clearly

 

5-6-1 Castillo

 

fair explaination, i just respectfully disagree. i saw a lot of punches landing to the short ribs but you're right, the punchstats were very generous to castillo. they counted a lot that didn't land effectively but i'll take 5 thudding body shots to 10 flicker jabs that barely land. i also think it goes both ways, mayweather's jabs (which is all he threw for the second half) were not landing as much as advertised and often barely scrapped the tip of castillos nose