How did you score De la Hoya's close or controversial fights

- Whitaker fight - a draw
- Quartey fight - Quartey by a point
- Trinidad fight - a draw
- Mosley 1 fight - Mosley by 4 points
- Mosley 2 fight - Mosley by 2 points
- Sturm fight- DH by 2 points
- Mayweather fight - Mayw by 2 points

 

He lost to Sturm, clearly. It was a gift win for Oscar or if you prefer a robbery.

The decision was met with controversy as the Compubox punch stats showed that Sturm had a clear edge over De La Hoya in nearly every category.

Sturm would land 234 of his 541 thrown punches for a 43% success rate, and though De La Hoya would throw well over 200 more punches than Sturm, landed only 188 of his 792 for only a 24% success rate. Sturm also dominated De La Hoya with his jab, landing 112 jabs to De La Hoya's 58. De La Hoya narrowlyoutlanded Sturm in power punches, connecting with 130 of 394 for 33%, however, Sturm still managed to land over half of his power punches going 122 of 235 for 52%. After the bell had sounded, Sturm celebrated, thinking he had done enough to earn the victory. HBO commentators [url]Jim Lampley[/url] and [url]Roy Jones, Jr.[/url] both felt Sturm had clearly won, while unofficial scorer [url]Harold Lederman[/url] also had Sturm the winner with the score of 115–113, scoring six of the last seven rounds for Sturm

 

De la Hoya vs Pernell Whitaker (116-112 for De la Hoya)
De la Hoya vs Ike Quartey (114-113 for Quartey)
De la Hoya vs Felix Trinidad (115-113 for De La Hoya)
De la Hoya vs Shane Mosley 1 (116-112 for Mosley)
De la Hoya vs Shane Mosley 2 (116-112 for De La Hoya)
De la Hoya vs Felix Sturm (115-113 for Sturm)
De la Hoya vs Floyd Mayweather (116-112 for Mayweather)

 

Pernell Whitaker Draw. Neither guy deserved the win. It was a non fight but Oscar was exposed as an unfinished product.

Ike Quartey I had Quartey by a point. He controlled the fight but Oscar had that huge last round.

Felix Trinidad. Tito by 1 point. I called a few of those early rounds even.

Mosely won clear in fight 1 and close in fight 2.

Sturm. Easy

Mayweather. 8-4 Floyd.

 

Just curious about your scorecard for the Whitaker fight. It looked like DelaHoya was missing and frustrated most if not all of that fight. Pea wasn't doing anything either but probably should have been a rematch.

 

I had him losing Mosley 1 and Mayweather.

I had him winning the others (Quartey is foggy) and either having a draw or losing to Sturm.

 

I thought Quartey and Sturm beat him and that he beat Tito.

 

Whitaker - Whitaker or Draw
Ike - Ike by a point or so
Felix - Oscar by two points
Mosley 1 - Clear win for Mosley
Mosley 2 - Draw
Sturm - Sturm by two points
Floyd - Floyd by two points.

 

Pernell Whitaker - Whitaker
Ike Quartey - Quartey
Felix Trinidad - De La Hoya
Shane Mosley 1 - Mosley
Shane Mosley 2 - De La Hoya
Felix Sturm - Sturm
Floyd Mayweather - Floyd

 

I haven't heard any real controversy surrounding Mosley I or Mayweather, and I think DLH lost them both. Gave Mayweather his second most competitive fight though, and didn't lose by much.

I had him clearly outpointing Trinidad, Whitaker, and Mosley (II).

I scored Quartey a draw, and thought that it could have gone either way.

 

Thought Pea beat him in a close bout-he even dropped him.

Trinadad was a bad decision.

Strum got robbed.

Mosley won the first but should have lost the second.

Thought Oscar beat Quartey with the big last round.

Mayweather won by 3 points .

 

I thought Oscar clearly won the Felix Trinidad fight and the Shane Mosley rematch.

I thought Oscar lost the Sturm fight.

The rest were fine.

 

I don't think he deserved the Whittaker win. It was close but it never felt like he took the tittle off the champion. Whittaker should have kept his tittle.

Trinidad even. He lost it by the way he fought.

I thought he edged the quartet fight. Very close though.

Was lucky getting a SD loss v Mosley. He lost that one. Thought he won the 2nd though.

Lost to Sturm

Lucky again to get a SD loss v fmj he clearly lost that one. Prob 8/4.