How does Joe deserve to leap Pacquiao as #2 P4P?

but pacquiao got whooped by medgeon singsurat
:rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl

 

well Calzaghe never had all the belts at the same time, so by your reasoning he was never undisputed. Bute won the IBF belt before Calzaghe fought Kessler

Also, forget the stuff about lineal or not lineal. Check out this thread:

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=43454

are you gonna tell me that Pac is not undisputed?

 

He's not undisputed, he's the Ring champ. The lineal title will not be decided until someone annexe's all the 175lbs belts.

 

well if you think calzaghe is even better than mayweather then it shows..besides resume wise, pac wins by a mile. Calzaghe has only ruled one division..and pac has the better opposition.

 

Rutgers..does your name suggests that you went to Rutgers University?

 

yes I do agree with u, but what bears more weight is QUALITY OF OPPOSITION.

 

Ohh so you already know

 

if this was about resumes, floyd and pac are way ahead of calzaghe

 

yup

 

There is a very strong case for JC jumping over PAc and thats that Pac really didnt win convincingly against JMM who was also a top p4p fighter.
JC dominated Hopkins and won a clear yet messed up decision. I really cant belive it was a SD. I think i had it 115-111 or something like that.
So if u take the way both of their fights went you can say that JC beat his man convincingly while many people cried robbery in Pacs fight.

 

however most people also agree that Marquez is way better than Hopkins at this point in their careers.

 

HAHAHAHAHA

Pacquiao SD12 Marquez

Read it again, maybe it'll be different.

 

pac is currently a 3-division linear (112, 126, 130) and a 4-weight (112, 122, 126, 130) champ. he stays @ #2 p4p with calzaghe @#3 and jmm @ #4. jmm was #3 p4p when pac won against him while hopkins was probably #8 or 9 when calzaghe beat him. another big difference is that jmm is very prime while hops is a 43-year old definitely past-prime fighter and calzaghe only won via SD just like pac.

 

i like jc but you are overrating him.. your logic is kinda ******ed. sorry:-(

 

hey divac i respect your boxing knowledge and you're quite a reasonable poster but when it comes to jmm's accomplishment you're simply a nuthugger and you are always going the pacdbest route.. i pity you