How does Khan's resume compare to those of Hatton, and Witter?

Hattons WBU years saw him take on some serious contenders. The likes of Phillips and Tackie were better than Paulie, let alone Salita and McCloskey.

 

Fought some terrible bums in the WBU reign of terror mind.

 

Very good level headed post mate, props :good

 

Of course.

 

Paulie was a name to get him credit in the u.s
Salita was mandatory (and the easiest mandatory in recent history)

Tackie was poor, his only attribute is the fact he was hard as nails, hatton totally dominated him iirc :good

Phillips I aint seen so not gonna comment.

 

I have the odd moments of clarity!!

 

Gaz my point now is that I firmly believe Hatton lost those fights (no kt cos the towel went in to end that fight).

Now after seeing those cards i am still undetered cos I dont go on scorecards unless its a fighter dominating a card. Sturm v Macklin and Williams v Lara make my point for me, granted magee fight was a pick em for many or a hatton for you. But the callazo he got beat hand down yet lost on a ud, i mean like wtf?

 

What do you want me to say mate? I scored Hatton-Collazo and if you thought Collozo nicked it then fair enough but to say Hatton got beat "hands down" is ridiculous.

You scored it for Collazo by 1 round? How is that "hands down"?

 

How did he get beat hands down if you only had Collazo winning by one point??

And how did he lose the fight to Tszyu if he stopped him?

And if Magee beat Hatton, how did he manage to lose 9 rounds on 2 scorecards? Judges can get it wrong, but not by that much normally.

 

My bad, when i say hands down i dont mean a shut out, i meant it was glaringly obvious. That fight was fairly clear iirc, hattons work looked dogged and forced and he hated the southpaw stance. Callazo didnt have his best night and beat ricky fair and square.

Agree to disagree on the fight if need be, but its worth another watch cos when you see hatton struggle his way thru now its hard to justify his win...

 

Zoo would have won should he not have retired, that is what i meant.

Watch magee fight again and tell em how the **** hatton won by 9 rounds...

 

some good points boys.....and who the **** says resume yank shite its a c.v innit!!!...but yeah its a record.

id like to see khan go 10 rounds with a prime mayweather and a moody ref.

 

Fine mate but I can't see how a 1 round difference is even glaringly obvious. Its a close fight, surely? I've Hatton winning by 1 point but I'd never say it was glaringly obvious he won, he got the nod in a close fight.

 

He could whack a bit as well, Hatton dominating is a good thing :good

Phillips of course did this:

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xpPA2u1iLNE[/ame]

And was a useful fighter for a few years.

 

Verno Phillips is it? did hatton fight the decent version of him or the typical 'on the slide' fighter frank normally drafts in.