How does your p4p top 10 look now?

GSP, Fedor, Silva and Penn remain my top 4.

Machida didn't win that fight at all.

 

Yes, I now have it like this.....

1. Fedor
2. Anderson
3. Rua
4. GSP
5. Penn
6. Machida

Ps. There is close to 0 between numbers 2-5 tho & they could swap with no argument from me but.... Machida cannot rank higher than any of those 5 guys at the moment IMO & Fedor is solid at no1.

 

Rua higher than GSP is a bad call imo.

 

I dont mind if GSP is ranked higher than Rua at the moment, my list is on the basis that I think Shogun at his peak (Pride version) is a touch better than GSP & I think Shogun looked back to that form in his last 2 fights, he just beat the most on form p4per in Machida who a lot of people had in their top 4 or 5 before this fight, he must at least take the place of Machida, whether thats ahead of GSP or not.

:good

 

haha im a big rua fan but puttin him above gsp after 2 good fights is not good
my p4p

1.gsp
2.fedor
3.silva
4.penn
5.rua
6.machida
7.fitch
8.brown
9.alves
10.henderson

 

I have no problem with GSP being higher but putting GSP over Fedor is not good either IMO.

 

Agreed. Fedor is basically of the charts in all departments, I don't see how you could rank anyone above him.

 

how is GSP making people's #1 when he hasn't fought outside the division and proven himself against bigger competition while others like Silva have

 

do u know what p4p means its not about fighting bigger people its taking a fighters skill set and comparing it to another fighters! gsp imo is the best fighter p4p in the world
best wrestler in mma! elite striker out hit alves! bjj black belt! add to that he's probably the best athlete in mma fast strong and to me p4p if he was born a nautral heavy he'd beat fedor's ass! silva would get whooped aswell if he were a nautral middle!

just my opinion tho people!

 

Noone would whip Fedor's ass, ever.

 

Very true, that shits impossible.

 

1. fedor
2. gsp
3. anderson
4. bj penn
5. machida
6. rua

 

>Rua
>Rated higher than GSP or Penn

HAAAAAAA.

 

lol @ Machida still being mentioned. Tell me he's not overrated... The guy is not even top LHW and somehow he still makes the list. Bet you both Rampage and Anderson would would Machida's ass at 205, not to mention Tito in a rematch after Shogun whoops Machida again.