How good was George Godfrey?

Stop being a whiner. Stay on the subject in the threads. Whenever you do not like something, it seems you feel the need to do something like this or create some new thread.

I did not see Moore vs Valdes on film to judge. I think Moore won the fight, but it was controversial in some quarters.

I did see Godfrey vs Carena on film to judge. This is the difference. Godfrey vs Carnera was not a one sided fight as you ascertain.