How Good Was Tony Tucker? Is he a HOF

Two words.

Herbie Hide.

 

I was referring to Vitali. People sometimes inflate Corrie too in order to make Vitali better. Corrie had great skills, and so did Tucker, but neither became what they could have, and fans of Vitali and Tyson, repsectively, inflate these men to inflate their guy.

 

He was 34 when he fought lewis..............but came in in great shape at 235 lbs.......i dont think tucker was shot when he fought lewis..........so0 igive lewis thumbs up for beating a tough big heavyweight...........but i do not think he is a hof boxer

 

Grand Rapids in the house !!

 

Exactly. That sums it up perfectly.:good

 

Very good fighter who's drug use and knee injury messed up what could have been a better career.Had no business losing in the Western Olympic Finals in 1980 either, but that's another story.

 

No..Lennox Lewis faced a decent Tucker who had just recorded victories over Oliver McCall and Orlin Norris who were 2 of the better fighters in the division on and around that period. Those fights gave Tucker his mandatory position against Lewis and he was a live opponent and was 34 years of age and not 45 as you mentioned above.......

 

yeh everyone has bad losses when they comeback a shot fighter.

 

he'd also gone through drug rehab several times by then.

He was faded against lewis but not shot.


Only drugs, and Tyson, stopped tucker achieving HoF and even ATG status, best hw fighter of the 80s bar Tyson and holmes IMHO.

 

about corrie, yes he was mediocre but got lucky against a weak h2h champ.

but tucker had skills you only have to watch him fight. He wasn't far off outpointing Tyson with a bad hand too.

 

why on earth would a bonafide hw champion be defending against a 40something?

 

Tucker was a very good fighter could have been dominant without outside personal issues and management hassle a classic case of what if ?

 

Good fighter but no.. Not Hall of game material..