How will you rate Froch if he wins Super six, undefeated?

Certainly as the number 1 in the division.

Anything else would be a joke!!!

 

p4p#1atg

 

P4p TOP 10.

 

p4p top ten

 

P4P top five without question.

As for the British ATG list, certainly above Hatton, Haye, Hamed and Calzaghe.

 

I'll rate him highly in his division
But P4P? hmmmmm

 

He'll have beaten Pascal, Taylor, Dirrell, Kessler, Abraham and, depending on the draw, Green and Ward (Green won't last in the tourney but I think Froch will def. have to get through Ward at some point).


Thats a great set of wins in anyones book. If thats not P4P tp 10 form then I don't know what is.

 

Highly in his division? With the exception of Bute he'll have beaten pretty much every top fighter in the division....

 

I would rate him as a serial overachiever.

But still not P4P. He is a basic and awkward fighter with no real skill.

I quite like Froch, he speaks a lot of sense and can be quite funny, seems a good guy. Having said that I dont particularly enjoy watching his ugly style, and I think he is genuinely delusional as to his level of ability.

 

A win over darchinyan seems to be enough for most people these days :think

 

As far as I'm concerned, he's already lost to Dirrell.

But yeah, it would be a great achivement if he were to win it.

 

when you look at those wins though, how good are they really? some were over the hill others really unproven others shown to have serious limitations.it is a good set of wins certainly but those names arnt exactly p4p themselves(yet?). if he wins it he will be certainly p4p top 10, somewhere around 8 for me. if he comes through undefeated, then fights the still undefeated lucian bute and wins,then fights a moving up kelly pavlik, then go's up to 175 and beats chad dawson then he would be p4p 1!

 

you would have to rate him as the best super middleweight ever which means ATG

 

Put it this way, theres fighters in the P4P top 10 with far less impressive wins.

Taylor was on the slide but if he beats Kessler and AA are we going to say they were past it too? Boxers can't win these days!!