How would Calzaghe do against these fighters?

Outbox Collins sure, but Watson?

 

I guess Tarver was available there near the end, when both were past it. Otherwise no, he didn't have many world class southpaws in proximity versus whom to prove his mettle.

 

Whatever

 

smash them all with ease best ever super middleweigt and not a drugs cheat like roy the fraud jones.

 

JC would dominate in any era

 

You sure about that?

How about prior to inception of the 168lb division?

In the 60's, is he dominating middleweights like Benvenuti, Archer, Giardello, Fullmer, & Tiger - or light heavyweights like Moore, Foster, Peralta, Bobo, & Chegui? :think

It's either or. He can only go up or down. There was no 168.

 

.... as long as he would hold his chin his fast hands would make the difference
like it or not there is no answer to his fast flurries

 

...against the entire dozen names I listed? :yikes

Fast hands make the difference for Calzaghe against Dick Tiger?? (To be clear, at 160.) Or Nino Benvenuti?

Archie Moore or Bob Foster @ 175??

 

You've been here a while, why are you bothering with a Slappy fan? They all literally think he's a top 5 overall ATG.

If Tua had gone undefeated fighting bums in NZ then beat a washed up Tyson we'd see the same type of insane fanbase insisting against facts that he was the GOAT.

 

Is it too late for Tua vs. Tyson? :think

 

Still seeing recent YouTube comments about Wlad ducking Tua. These guys don't give up

 

I even saw one joker claiming Tua would KO Calzaghe!!

What absolute chicanery. :-(

 

Sir Jos has a well established and time tested iron mandible.

Only true hitters like a 43 year old Hopkins, shot to **** RJJ, and a couple bums can put down such a warrior. Tua gets outworked to a UD12.