How would Floyd do against the boxers who beat Shane?

Mayweather beats Cotto via a clear decision, but loses to Winky and Vernon. Both of them are bad styles for Floyd.

 

Wright easily.

Forrest UD.

Cotto SD.

 

so a natural 135 pounder hits as hard as a 154 pounder who went as high as 168?

 

And insted of fighting the Welterweight with 5 losses he went and fought the Lightweight with 4 losses.

Cotto I say would lose by decision.

Forrest wins by decision.

Wright would TKO Floyd in the late rounds.

 

Winky has the best chance, Floyd beats the rest including Forrest.

 

Floyd would have beaten Cotto on points, in a convincing style.

I think Winky and Forrest would both have won decisions. Their size advantage along with their great jabs, would have been too much for Floyd.

 

He would have at least six losses.

 

Floyd beats Cotto and Forrest at 147.

Winky beats Floyd at 154, absolutely no doubt about it.