How would rank the following welterweights in terms of overall toughness?

Consider the following: The ability to take single or combination shots to the head, body, and general recovery ability.

Rank them 1 - 10. All welterweights are in their prime. The welterweights are:

Ray Leonard
Roberto Duran
Oscar Dela Hoya
Shane Mosley
Henry Armstrong
Floyd Mayweather
Charley Burley
Julio Cesar Chavez
Manny Pacquiao
Kid Gavilan

 

Ray Leonard 9
Roberto Duran 9
Oscar Dela Hoya 9
Shane Mosley 9
Henry Armstrong 9
Floyd Mayweather 9
Charley Burley 9
Julio Cesar Chavez 8.5
Manny Pacquiao 8
Kid Gavilan 10

 

I meant in numerical order as I don`t think they are all on the same level in terms of toughness. I would put them like this:

1. Gavilan
2. Leonard
3. Mosley
4. Armstrong
5. Duran
6. Dela Hoya
7. Mayweather
8. Burley
9. Chavez
10. Pac

Thoughts?

 

1. Galivan
2. Armstrong
3. Mosley
4. Burley
5. Leonard
6. Duran
7. Oscar
8. Mayweather
9. Chavez
10. Pacquiao

 

Out of the ones I've watched


Ray Leonard 10
Roberto Duran 10
Oscar Dela Hoya 8
Shane Mosley 8
Floyd Mayweather 8.5
Julio Cesar Chavez 9
Manny Pacquiao 8

 

1. Julio Cesar Chavez
2. Roberto Duran
3. Kid Gavilan
4. Ray Leonard
5. Charles Burley
6. Shane Mosley
7. Henry Armstrong
8. Manny Pacquiao
9. Oscar De La Hoya
10. Floyd Mayweather - partially because we dont see him get hit clean often enough to judge

 

lol, likes like most of you fools dont even know who chavez is.

 

De la hoya, Duran, Mayweather, Pac, Burley, Chavez, etc. were not primed at welterweight.

 

Well, he keeps dragging up junior welter and lightweights up to 147 :think

 

:think

 

In my opinion Dela Hoya was still in the prime of his career when he took on Mosley at welter, Duran when he took on Leonard and so on. That said, Dela Hoya, Duran, Mayweather and Chavez certainly peaked (were at their best) at lightweight. Just my opinion though.

 

I think you have underrated Oscar and Shane a bit. They were never KO'd or TKO'd at welterweight. Moreover, both of them have had fights with big time punchers at welterweight. I think they are on the same level as Chavez.

 

All 10's.

 

I love Mosley and he certainly is tough but he got hurt in the 2nd or 3rd round by Forrest and was hurt the rest of teh fight. He never fully recovered. Now its awesome that he lasted and didnt get KO but still. Ive seen Floyd hurt like that twice and in alot of people's mind he came back to win the round or atleast made it close while taking over completely in the following round

 

Seriously those guys are as tough as it gets. Throw Basilio in there and those may be the toughest list of welters ever.