3, was a bit better than I expected......and Cotto showed that he is a bit more competitive than expected....even so, we all knew the result before the fight and because of that we can“t say it was FOTY contender or anything like that.....I see that way.
I'd rate it a 4. You had two highly skilled fighters, who both fought well, in a competitive fight. However, there were no knockdowns, it went the distance, and Mayweather had the fight in the bag in the championship rounds. Very good fight, but not FOTY material.