How wud u sort dem according 2 ich 1 of diz categories?

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by frankenfrank, Jun 13, 2013.


  1. frankenfrank

    frankenfrank Boxing Junkie Full Member

    13,965
    68
    Aug 18, 2009
    Salvador Sanchez
    Mike McCallum
    Michael Carbajal
    Julio Cesar Chavez
    Roberto Duran
    Carl Froch

    1) durability (not just during prime but also overall during 1's career)
    2) quality of wins vs best (in h2h terms) 5 opponents
    3) h2h ability / 4midability of best 5 opponents (as opposed 2 how gr8 dei wer p4p)

    4) overcoming physically superior opponents
    5) reliance on physicality
    6) punching ability
    7) faiting according 2d ruls

    hir i go :
    1) durability :
    Roberto Duran
    Mike McCallum / Julio Cesar Chavez / Carl Froch
    Salvador Sanchez / Michael Carbajal

    2) quality of wins vs best 5 opponents :

    Duran :
    Leonard
    Barkley
    Marcel
    Adolfo Viruet
    Edwin Viruet / Saoul Mamby

    McCallum :
    Jackson
    Curry
    Ramzi Ibrahim
    Watson (probably drained)
    Jeff Harding

    Froch :

    Kessler
    Dirrell
    Abraham
    Taylor
    Robin Reid

    HM : Glen Johnson , Lucian Bute , Jean Pascal

    Chavez :

    Meldrick Taylor
    Edwin Rosario
    Hector Camacho
    Greg Haugen
    Lonnie Smith


    Carbajal :
    Melchor Cob Castro (woz it rili e win ?)
    Gonzalez (Carbajal almost stopped himself , Gonzalez not de most durable)
    Kitikasem (probably drianed)
    Arce (might b over8ed)
    Jesus Chong

    3) top 5 opponents according 2 h2h ability 4midability :

    Duran : Hagler , Hearns , Leonard*3 , Marcel , Sims
    HM : Barkley , Buchanan , DeJesus*3 , Benitez , Adolfo Viruet , Edwin Viruet*2 , Saoul Mamby , Jose Cuevas , Palomino , Jorge Castro*2 , William Joppy , Camacho*2 , Pazienza

    McCallum : Fabrice Tiozzo , RJJ , Jeff Harding , Julian Jackson , Sumbu*2 Kalambay
    HM : Donald Curry , Steve Collins , James Toney*3 , Herol Graham

    Sanchez : LaPorte , Nelson , Gomez , Lopez*2 , Ruben Castillo
    HM : Antonio Beccera , Juan Escobar , Pat Ford

    Froch :
    Ward , Kessler , Dirrell , Abraham , Pascal
    HM: Taylor , Robin Reid , Glen Johnson , Bute

    Carbajal : Melchor Cob Castro , Humberto Gonzalez , Arce , Kitikasem , Pastrana
    HM : Jake Matlala , Jesus Chong

    Chavez : DeLahoya*2 , Tszyu , Rosario (at least on paper) , LaPorte , Ramirez
    HM : Miguel Angel Gonzalez , Camacho , Haugen , Taylor*2 , Whitaker , Lockridge



    4) overcoming physically superior opponents :
    1) Duran : Leonard , Barkley
    2) McCallum : Watson , Harding , Collins
    3-6) Chavez / Carbajal / Sanchez / Froch

    5) reliance on physicality :
    Carbajal , Sanchez , Froch
    Chavez
    McCallum
    Duran

    6) punching ability :

    1,2,3) Sanchez / Carbajal / Duran
    4,5) McCallum / Froch
    6) Chavez

    7) faiting according 2d ruls :

    1,2) Sanchez / Carbajal
    3) Froch
    4) Chavez
    5,6) McCallum , Duran


    overall :
    1) Duran : won categories 1-6 , lost category 7
    I ken not split de rest rait naw , haw wud u ?

    & haw wud u fit Shane Mosley in ?