I actually think Brook would beat Broner.

Our Kel would smoke his boots.

 

Who has Broner beat? He has cherry picked all his opponents.

 

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

 

P4P Rees and DeMarco are better than anybody Brook has beat and Malignaggi is better than anybody Brook has faced and is better than Brook.

Broner would get Saldivia and Jones quicker out there (Jones without needed a rematch) and would stop Matthew Hatton easily.

Brook is one of the most over hyped British fighters ever, when he's exposed you'll all pretend that you knew from the start.

 

This will be a very interesting thread to look at a few years down the line. A few people might look a little silly either way

 

How do you know Broner definitely punches harder? Malignaggi certainly doesn't think he does.

You commend Broner's defense saying he has the ability to take shots yet conveniently forget he hasn't fought a big puncher yet. Paulie was carefully selected for a reason.

Broner is currently nowhere near the elite at 140 or 147.

 

Nobody at 140 would beat him. He's never faced a puncher which is why I said I feel his defence is lacking - it doesn't need to be anything else.

Malignaggi doesn't think so? The Showtime camera's must have been lying then when they showed his head snap back after every punch.

 

Maligaggi's opinion > a camera shot

Look at the state of Paulie after the Broner fight vs the Cotto fight - no contest.

Matthysse would utterly destroy Broner.

 

And anyone who thinks Kell Brook is barely above domestic class is a ******.:roll:

 

I'm really not much of a Brook believer, but I figure he beats Broner.

 

atsch Matthysse would destroy broner, paulie was tagging him all night long, if paulie had a punch he would of beaten broner, I think Kell wins also.

 

No one on here's saying Brook's elite, its just the majority think he's better than Broner. IF Brook fights one of the elite guy's and gets as you say 'exposed', not many on the Brit forum would be surprised.

Broners really not that great. Never mind Brook, i'd put money on Frankie 'well conditioned' Gavin beating him :yep

 

He almost beat him without a punch.that fight was very close apart from the ******ed scorecard who gave broner it by about ten rounds.i think paulie deserved at least a drawer in that down to his fantastic workrate.broner did **** all and was lucky to get the decision

 

Brook hasn't even fought anyone nearly as good as Malagnaggi yet!

 

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected