I think all these people beat Mayweather - agree?

Dont know about Sanchez and Pep...I think Floyd is a bad style for Willie and just holds to many physical advantages.
Salvador is a better shot IMO but its hard to speculate because he was never able to test himself higher against the bigger guys.

Armstrong is a good call but you could argue that either way IMO.

I gotta say in Floyd's era, over 12...Id pick him to edge out Arguello. Alexis started slow generally and took even longer to contend with boxer types of Floyd's ilk. Just think he runs out of time over the 12 and its a bit unfair to chuck floyd in a 15 rounder.

I think Whitaker, Duran and Chavez beat him without a doubt. Ross id instill a slight favorite, he is very well rounded but Floyd could pose him a lot of problems.

De la Hoya beats him at 140-147 more often then not.

Hard call with Pryor, he sort of never really proved himself against a range of high class fighters, just a couple and no one with the style of Floyd. But I do side with him ever so slightly. His unconventional style, workrate, natural strength and offensive ability all spell poison for a guy like Money.

To tell you the truth I give Floyd an edge over the pup version of Wilfred. He is a better lateral mover and a little more polished then the very young version of WB at 140. At 147 its a different story, at 154 Id back Wilfred with little hesitation.

All those guys at 147 either beat him easily or stop him..But I at least give Mayweather a chance to eek it out over Tito...And you could add a ton more at that weight where I feel Floyd just wasnt that impressive.

Floyd was magic at 130...very few under modern rules over 12 rounds I pick over him there but he just lost a little bit when the weight was stacked on against the decent opposition he took on above his best weight.

 

i reckon he beats JCC at SFW and i reckon he would slip past Tszyu and ODLH at 140... stylistically he is just not right for either of them. Tszyu would patiently wait 12 rounds waiting to land that big shot and i dont think he would land it. Close fights but i see Floyd edging them. At 147 i reckon he beats Trinidad in a great fight. Hearns would give Floyd fits with that laser like right hand over the top

 

Chavez wouldn't win one round against Floyd. At any weight at any time.

 

Because he has never fought over that distance.

Floyd doesnt have the punch to trouble Az but lesser boxers have been able to trouble Pryor with varying success.
He will be in whirlwind mode, which will see him fairly easy for Floyd to find. Just think if Floyd fights disciplined and at range he will get his fair share of rounds and run Pryor pretty close.

I used to be in the Mosley beats Floyd at lightweight boat but Ive changed sides. Wont argue with anyone who sees it the other way, just I think Shane's body of work there is getting a little overrated now.

 

They surely would...if anything I think the fact he have gone 15 puts little doubt on whether they can handle a decent pace over 12.

But I dont think you could say it works the other way definitively.

 

Well he is superbly conditioned...and paces himself very well.

But no one has ever really pushed him the way guys like Armstong or Arguello most certainly will. Even over 12 he tends to pack up shop for spells.

IMO its just another 3 rounds for the punchers to get at him. I tend to think a lot of names you mentioned would be the ones finishing with a gallop and not Floyd.

 

Harsh Appo. Tszyu's career post Vince Phillips went a little haywire with injuries and a cockhead manager, although his fighting ability suffered little. Even though Kostya is one of the most suffered fighters on record (In saying his career was disturbed at every corner) I back him against any jW/W, especially a southpaw.