James Toney embarrassed Peter big time in the first fight. 260lb beast in Peter was slapped into perspective when he fought 12 rounds with a former middleweight and the so called hardest hitter in boxing couldn't KO him. I'm sure Peter was shocked, And he knows he lost that first fight...It eats me up alive when I remember Peter running back to his locker room like that...HE LOST THAT FIRST FIGHT...It would have been a kick ass win for James Toney who at the end of his career could have really used that type of win. So in all I think James Toney hurt Peters confidence more than anything.