I want an insite into the mind of those rating Bernard Hopkins amongst the top 5 P4P

And why are you CLEARLY exaggerting to try and justify your point? I was talking about Tito fighting at MW. AFTER he was at 154 for a couple years. THEN moving to MW, where he fought and demolished a very skilled titleholder.

And you repond with nonesense about Floyd, who started at 130, and Pac, who started at 112, fighting at HW and losing to Wlad? atsch

You are clearly reaching for something, but there's nothing for you to grab.

 

I remember Trinidad ranked #3 by most major boxing publications and so called experts. And Hopkins didnt just beat him, he dismantled him when a LOT of tito nuthuggers were by looking past Hops and thinking Tito could beat RJ. Nobody else molested Joppy before or since tito and that means nothing? Who else at middleweight couldve domintated your boy like that besides hopkins? If it wasnt for hops, tito wouldve been middleweight champ until Winky came along and beat his ass.

 

You have no superior insight, that's obvious. You're just a stuck up poster looking to ruffle feathers. Rather juvenile for someone who thinks they are above everyone else.:roll:

 

They are trying to take things into the prober context. Beating RJJ of the now doesn't equate doing it 8 years ago.

 

No **** it doesn't. Who said beating RJJ TODAY would do that? Like, NO ONE?:huh

You want to talk proper context, try using an example IN PROPER CONTEXT. :deal

 

Yeah, China hand is in rare form tonight....

 

I disagree...Fighters, even those on the elite level, are CONSTANTLY improving themselves... So Calzaghe in his PRO debut, would NOT have been the same fighter as Calzaghe vs Jeff Lacy...

 

Some of this stuff is just brilliant.:yep :good

 

No, you're exaggerating because that's the best you can do and ALL you can do. You tried to make a point and failed miserably. That's a fact son. :deal

Which P4P lists change on a weekly basis BTW? Please explain, becuase I don't deal in generalizations. Ring Magazine only changes their after a fighter listed fights. And not always then either.

 

He wouldn't have won every round off Jeff Lacy in 2000-to about 2003/4 (the guy that fought Reid could have possibly even lost)... And if he doesn't win every round off Jeff Lacy, he ain't in ANYONE's pound 4 pound top ten...