I was challenged to do this so I have: My Castillo-Mayweather I Scorecard

Good post:good

 

Thats what was reported after the fight to this writer no surgery was done was there?

 

Another pathetic thread by a rePactard lol. They have to say Floyd lost because Floyd's undefeated record says that Floyd is better than Pac to *******s lol. Blam, right in your face...lol. Never mind that Pac lost twice by ko in 3 rounds to bums, and never rematched them. Guys say Floyd lost a close fight to Castillo, yet say Pac beat Marquez in both fights. It's despicable lol. The OP is the worst rePactard ever too.

Even if you thought Castillo won, the fight was close enough to pick either man. Castillo hardly hit Floyd, but he was busy landing what he could on Floyd. He used his weight advantage and great pressure o stay in the fight...but he never BEAT Floyd. So what did Floyd do, when there was controversey...he confronted it full on, and gave the champ a rematch...and won clearly.

You guys who say Castillo won the first fight can't score a fight, and you let your pathetic "fit in with other posters" bias affect your true scoring of the fight. You guys can't even watch a fight and tell who is landing the cleaner punches.

I remember when they said Forrest lost to Mayorga in the rematch...that was disgusting. Watching that rematch, Mayorga hardly hit Forrest, and Mayorga was probably coked up in that fight too. They said Mayorga won too....comical. Don't act like Lederman's scorecard is truth because there are plenty of times his card read assinine lol...and you know it. Pac fans say Floyd lost to Castillo, yet say Pac beat Marquez both times and never produce footage of PAc's early 3 round ko losses. Shite thread, and I'm out lol...

 

She copied and pasted that.

 

Another thing, scoring rounds 10-10 is a complete joke...especially in championship fights lol. Another reason why the OP rat ass shouldn't be respected. Tattle tale lol...

 

After reading through this whole thread, I am now convinced of several things.

1) PBF won this fight.
2) Peoples hate for PBF stand in their way of sound reasoning and fairness.
3) PBF will never win a fight in many peoples mind unless he dominates similar to Baldomir.

I think if you really want to prove that PBF lost, forget about lederman and Larry Merchant and show:

The seven rounds that JLC won from rounds 5 to 12. Even if they are not dominant rounds just show the 7 rounds you think he won.:deal

 

Id still like an explanation for giving the 3rd round to Castillo or calling it even. One guy is landing and the other one isnt. Whats so hard about that?

 

114-112 Castillo



Mayweather: 1,2,3,4 and 9
Castillo: 5,6,7,10 ( 10-8 ) ,11 and 12
Round 8 even ( 9-9 )

 

I thought round 10 and 11 were clearly Mayweathers

 

I must've watched this fight at least 15 times and always see new things that I did'nt see before.

The last time I watched this fight I gave it to Floyd because I gave the first 5 rounds all to him, the 3rd round is not debateable, Floyd clearly won that round and the 5th round could swing Castillo's way but one would have to reach for him in that round and some of the punches Castillo landed towards the end of round 5 were after the bell so you can't count that as a reason why you gave that round to him.

 

So much pressure came from fans that a rematch was ordered. Castillo won the first fight, no doubt about it, but the judge are always in favor of Void.

 

So much pressure?


Floyd went after the rematch right away.